Goodwin says scouting AHL players requires at least a three- or four-game sample set: "Top players in the OHL might dominate, while AHL players are all fighting and scraping…in the AHL, the first year as a pro can be toughest. You are on your own, planning your own meals, playing against everyone who wants to make it [to the NHL]…it's a real grind, a difficult league to score in, playing against men, handling your mentality when teammates get called up instead of you… consistency and perseverance are important."
As a player, Goodwin says he compensated "for not being the fastest skater" by studying his opponents, learning their tendencies when shooting, maneuvering in the faceoff and more. He constantly studied which players were performing well for other teams. When he coached, he quizzed his players about the previous night's OHL games to teach them that "you learn the league, whether NHL, OHL or AHL."
As a player, coach, camp instructor and now scout, Goodwin fully embraces the process of projecting a hockey player's career trajectory to advance to the OHL or NHL.
"I have always been pretty accurate for the most part," he says. "You know which kids are driven who put in the extra work. You observe players who are taking short cuts and guys who don't. Those who play a different style when the score is close, have a different body language."
Goodwin is forthright about applying his own experience as a pro hockey prospect to his new job. He went undrafted in two consecutive NHL drafts, prompting his now brother-in-law and then juniors hockey reporter Bob McKenzie, a famed NHL insider for North American television networks, to write personally about Goodwin's undrafted status: "There may worse hockey-related kicks in the teeth, but I am not sure I can come up with one."
"I have learned what scouts look for," says Goodwin. "I went through two drafts and didn't get drafted. I can see now some reasons why that happened, what scouts look for and how they project [potential career success]. I played with teammates who went on to long NHL careers that maybe I never thought would have long NHL careers. Now I see why. That part of the sport has always intrigued me."