The Flyers trading Mike Richards in the summer of 2011 may have been one of the biggest trades in the modern NHL Era.
At the time of the trade, Richards had already won the Memorial Cup, the Calder Cup, a World Junior Gold Medal and an Olympic Gold Medal. He had been named to the Memorial Cup All-Star team, the NHL All-Star Team (2008), and he had led the Flyers over the Boston Bruins in a playoff series in which they trailed 3-0, a feat that hadn't been accomplished in 35 years.
The Kings had learned the value of depth after losing to the Sharks without an injured Anze Kopitar, and felt sure acquiring a player like Richards was crucial to escape the first round of the playoffs and contend for the Stanley Cup.
Then the Kings then double downed on their bet.
The team was struggling to score goals, so in the days leading up to the 2012 trade deadline, the Kings traded for another former Flyer.
Jeff Carter, who had previously been traded to the Columbus Blue Jackets on the same day as the Richards, was flipped to Los Angeles for Jack Johnson and a conditional 1st round pick. The price was steep, but the Kings were on the playoff bubble and couldn't afford to miss the postseason.
The rest, they say, is history.
We'll never know if the Kings would have acquired Carter from the Columbus Blue Jackets if they hadn't previously acquired Richards, but the end result was a locker room full of former Flyers hoisting the Stanley Cup in Los Angeles.
Fans still debate over who won the trade as Richards has departed from Los Angeles while Wayne Simmonds and Brayden Schenn continue to have productive careers in Philadelphia.
There are no absolute conditions to determine a trade winner, but while Richards was with the Kings he padded his resume with two Stanley Cup championships and became the only player in NHL history to win two playoff series after trailing 3-0.
There may never be a truly clear answer as to which team "won" the Mike Richards trade, but at least we know the Sharks lost.
No. 1 - Dean Lombardi