Washington wasn't able to convert on any of a number of strong scoring chances early in the game, as Coyotes goalie Antti Raanta made a number of impressive saves. The Caps overpassed themselves out of some opportunities as well, and they struggled to find consistency in the game's first 40 minutes. When they were able to break the Arizona forecheck, the Caps were able to generate odd-man rushes and looks at the other end. They were also successful when they were physical and exacted a toll on the Arizona defense with their own forecheck, but again they weren't consistent in that regard.
Ultimately, the Caps were undone by the first minute of the second period. Down 1-0 heading into the middle frame, the Capitals committed a pair of turnovers in neutral ice in the first 45 seconds of the period, and both of them ended up in the back of the Washington net. The second of those - a Christian Fischer tally from the top of the paint - required a lengthy video review to determine that it was indeed a goal, rather than a spectacular glove save from Ilya Samsonov.
"What we're going to take away is our first two periods," says Caps winger T.J. Oshie. "It was way too sloppy; a lot of standing around and trying to look for plays instead of skating. There was one line that was doing a lot of skating, one guy mostly, and that was [Evgeny Kuznetsov], and you saw how much success that he had. He is obviously on a different level than the rest of us, but a lot of success out of him because he was moving his legs and skating, that whole line was. They carried us tonight and got us back into it."
Kuznetsov scored midway through the second and early in the third to pull the Caps within one, and Oshie tied the game with 1:16 left in regulation, scoring on a rebound with Samsonov pulled for the extra attacker.