Coyotes defenseman Alex Goligoski carried deep into Washington ice and put the puck back out in front for Vinnie Hinostroza, who put a shot on net. Caps goalie Ilya Samsonov made the stop, but Clayton Keller poked the rebound home for a 1-0 Arizona lead at 14:15.
Washington was uncharacteristically sloppy in the first minute of the second, and it paid for its mismanagement of the puck. The Caps won the draw to start the second, but Michal Kempny promptly turned it over to Brad Richardson in neutral ice. Richardson carried deep into Washington territory and put the puck in front for Christian Fischer, whose shot was snared by Samsonov's glove hand. However, a lengthy video review showed that the puck was also over the goal line while it was nestled in the goalie's catching glove, and the Coyotes were up 2-0 just 12 seconds into the second.
Reirden appeared agitated over the call, but only because he didn't have access to the same angles the video review gurus were looking at to make their judgment.
"We're notified from Toronto on that," notes Reirden. "That's what happens during a situation like that, so that decision is being made from outside of our building.
"I just didn't have the angle - until later in the game - that showed that. So obviously the frustration from the angles I'm seeing on the bench, I think it's inconclusive. But obviously they're making the call; they have different angles than I do. Once I saw the other angle, I'm glad that I didn't argue it."
Thirty-three seconds later, a T.J. Oshie turnover turned into a Michael Grabner breakaway, which gave Arizona a 3-0 lead after he tucked a shot five-hole on Samsonov.
Washington clawed its way back, but it wasn't until the Caps were on the verge of going down four goals that they managed to get on the board. After an Oliver Ekman-Larsson point drive, Nick Jensen swept the crease of a loose and wobbling puck behind Samsonov, and seconds later Vrana sprung Evgeny Kuznetsov on a breakaway. Kuznetsov beat Raanta to make it a 3-1 game at 8:47.
Late in the second, Oshie drew a penalty that gave the Caps a carryover power play, and a chance to pull within a goal. Although Washington didn't score with the extra man, it did pull to within one shortly thereafter on Kuznetsov's second of the night.
Kuznetsov won a left dot draw back to Kempny at the left point. The latter fired a shot wide, and Kuznetsov pulled the rebound off the back wall and backhanded it behind Raanta from a severe angle, five seconds after the face-off win. The goal trimmed the Coyotes' lead to 3-2 at 2:23 of the third.