Murray and Penguins goalie Jeff Zatkoff each theorized that at least one frame of the video was removed, creating somewhat of an optical illusion.
"I didn't know about it until this morning when somebody showed me the video and it looks like somebody just kind of cut out one frame or something and I think it was probably doctored in some way," Murray said. "Pretty funny, nonetheless."
Zatkoff said Murray's glove failing would have been a nice excuse but did not afford his rookie teammate that luxury.
"If you watch it from the front, you can see blatantly that it goes over," Zatkoff said. "It looks like almost a frame's missing … It's obviously funny and it'd be better to say, 'It went through me, I had it, but my equipment malfunctioned.' But Stralman
The second was of a glove with the webbing removed:
Tweet from @RealDanaHeinze: Took a closer look - Matt Murray's Catch Glove Not sure how I missed this! pic.twitter.com/UQwgDNvTql
Zatkoff continued to debunk the conspiracy by delving into the intricacies of glove webbing.
"You'd feel the pull. Even through it went through, you would know it went through," Zatkoff said. "I never had it happen to me. I've had pucks go through the net, like in the net, but never in the webbing. I think we get enough gloves so frequently that the webbing never has enough time to stretch out that much where a puck could go through."
Murray fielded a fourth consecutive question regarding the controversy, smirked, tapped his glove and said, "I got the glove I was using yesterday right here."
"It's all in good fun," Murray said. "That's the Internet for you, I guess, nowadays."