Keith played in five NHL All-Star Games (1997, 1998, 1999, 2004, 2009) and knows something about the blend of skill and confrontation. He had consecutive 50-goal seasons (50 in 1995-96, 52 in 1996-97) and 2,219 career penalty minutes, with 147 or more penalty minutes in each of his first seven full NHL seasons (1992-99).
"When you're young and you're making your [mark] coming into the League, you have to provide that and establish yourself as an NHLer who plays hard," he said. "A lot of people don't realize Matthew has a lot of puck skills, that he's savvy. His game [now] is not like it was his first two years. But I like the fact that he plays that way, that he's learning how to still provide that but not as much as he did before. The edge is still there."
When it comes to deploying that edge, often sticking one's nose where it's not usually welcomed, timing is everything, Keith said.
"He's smart now, smart when he does it, and that's part of the maturing process," he said. "I get [mad] when he doesn't do it. That's the way he's got to play, first year or veteran. It makes him play better. It's not going and doing something ridiculous. It's little things.
"If he can go after and be hard on a guy ... he can take some heat off Johnny [Gaudreau] or [Sean Monahan], where that big, bad (former defenseman) Chris Pronger type is more interested in doing something to Matthew than he would be to those two. I don't think people understand that that's what he's trying to do. He's a team guy first. Things like that make him a valuable player on his team."
There is no better example of Tkachuk's skill and value this season than his game-winning goal against the Nashville Predators with 1.6 seconds remaining in overtime Oct. 31.
It was a bold move to decide to shoot the puck from between his legs from the slot and into the top corner over the right shoulder of Predators goalie Pekka Rinne. An Elias Lindholm shot attempt was blocked by Nashville's Matt Duchene and landed in front of Tkachuk, though not in an ideal spot.
"The puck just came to me in a position at the center of my body and I couldn't get my body around in time to make it a forehand or backhand, so I just decided to go with that," Tkachuk said. "It worked out, and I was pumped. I knew there wasn't much time and that I'd have to one-time it and that was the quickest way and the only way I was going to get a shot on net.
"I do it in practice every now and again, and I'll do it in warmups and occasionally in games. I do it enough that I can do it naturally."
That made his father laugh out loud.
"I've seen him do that as a kid and it used to drive me nuts if I'd see it in practice, but that's the new-age NHL," Keith said. "All these kids can do that. It's great for the game. I know in my prime, if I ever had one, that I couldn't ever do that. I would probably have fallen. It's impressive, as long as he doesn't go to the well too much with that."
Talbot said the play confirmed for him that Tkachuk's skills are underrated and all-star caliber.
"From where he was, how quickly the puck was coming to him, for him to have the wherewithal to pull it off, well, if I'm trying that, I'm probably pulling my groin," Talbot said. "For him to get it off with that kind of velocity, pick his spot and time on the clock, that's so impressive."