Islanders coach Jack Capuano said he was pleased to have Bailey's veteran presence back in the lineup for Game 3. He was even more impressed by his performance.
"You got a leader back," Capuano said. "He was out there for a little while and he was ready to play. [He was] questionable for Game 2 [in Tampa], but he came back and gave us a huge lift. I thought he played really well, got us a couple of big goals. I was really happy and pleased with the way Josh played.
"I know what Josh's capabilities are. It doesn't surprise me that he scored two goals. You just look at his stats year in and year out, he produces, and he's reliable defensively. It doesn't surprise me that he came in there and gave us a boost. That's what veteran guys do. He came in [and] he did the job."
Bailey nearly completed the hat trick in the third period. Twenty-eight seconds after Clutterbuck gave the Islanders a 4-3 lead, Bailey sent a wrist shot from the slot that seemed destined for the top right corner, but Bishop took it away with a dazzling glove save.
Bishop finished with 35 saves, including 16 in the first period. Islanders goalie Thomas Greiss made 36 saves.
"He's a great goalie; there's no secret about that," Bailey said of Bishop. "Two great goalies. We should have found a way to seal it before it got to overtime. It's unfortunate.
"We obviously had chances to put them away. We're disappointed in that. It's all part of the playoffs. You have these swings and momentum and ups and downs, and it's all part of the ride. Tomorrow's a new day and we'll be ready for Friday."