"Al was walking right behind me and Jean Potvin handed me the pie," Trottier said. "I just turned around and said 'Happy Birthday Al' and just plunked it in his face. I broke his glasses."
"Trots was not very delicate and still isn't," Clark Gillies said. "He certainly wasn't back in those days."
Trottier, the team's all-time leading scorer, was one of many Islanders who pied the late Hall of Fame coach, who won 740 games with the Islanders and passed away in 2015. It became a birthday tradition during his time with the Isles, though one that probably made the rookies holding the pie sweat more than the coach.
"It was designed to have a newcomer, preferably a rookie, get Al with a pie in the face," Gillies said. "[Al] was good about it. We had some guys, I forget which rookie it was, but he hit in the face with one of those tin foil plates and I think it left an impression of Al's face he hit him so hard."