Following the game, then rookie forward Luc Robitaille, who would go on to score 45 goals that season and win the Calder Trophy as the league's top first-year player, was quoted in the Edmonton Journal saying that he thought the Oilers were laughing at them as time ticked off the clock.
Whether or not their opponents were actually mocking them, Nicholls has no doubt that the Oilers were indeed probably having a chuckle at the expense of LA's performance.
"Oh they would be laughing the whole time because they were a cocky team and rightly so, they were great," he said. "By '86 they had won two in a row. They were in the middle of winning four Cups in five years, so they were so good. So young, so good. And they were cocky as hell and rightly so."
Nicholls credits Oilers coach Glen Sather for the team's attitude. "Their coach was, I don't want to say sarcastic because I loved Glen, but he was so confident," he said. "They would be joking and having fun and so would the coach, they were a reflection of the coach. And that's how Glen was."
But, of course, in this instance, the Kings got the last laugh.
"It was a win for us and definitely a loss for them, especially at home," Nicholls said. "We were taking the crowd out of the game, so obviously that was a lot of fun for us."
Although the Kings came back to tie it, it could have easily gone the other way.
"As a team and as players, you like to think you can win every game but when you played the Oilers in the '80s, there was a good chance you weren't going to win," Nicholls said.
Before the Kings went out for the third period that night trailing by three goals, Nicholls doesn't remember head coach Pat Quinn saying much in the dressing room.
"You can imagine the coach, but there's not much of a speech he's going to give us because he knows we're not winning anyway," he said. "It's not like the speech Herb Brooks gave the 1980 boys. He didn't think they could win either but you give that speech because if you get that momentum going you just never know."
And that's the greatest thing about sports, you just never know.