Reilly Smith tied it 3-3 with a short-handed goal 28 seconds into the third period. He took a stretch pass from Braden Schneider and scored with a shot from the top of the left circle that went over the blocker of Vejmelka and in under the crossbar.
“You always want to pick up at least half the points on a road trip,” Smith said. “To be able to cap it off with coming back tonight and picking up an extra [two points] is important.”
Chris Kreider gave the Rangers their first lead, 4-3, at 10:22. Carrick won a face-off back to Kreider, who skated into the high slot and scored with a shot that deflected in off the stick of Utah defenseman Ian Cole.
Panarin then scored his second goal of the game into an empty net at 19:22 for the 5-3 final.
“[Smith], obviously, got an important goal, and then everyone battled like a team,” Panarin said. “It was a great road trip for us (2-0-1), but we'll be ready for the next game.”
Maccelli gave Utah a 1-0 lead at 1:01 of the first period. He got to the rebound of Hayton's shot below the left circle and scored past a sprawling Shesterkin from a sharp angle.
Panarin responded at 3:42 to tie it 1-1. He beat Vejmelka glove side from the left circle off a pass from Alexis Lafreniere, who intercepted a pass from Utah defenseman Mikhail Sergachev below the goal line.