Instead, two seasons filled with injuries and disappointment followed.
"The year after, we had a lot of injuries and stuff, and last year, we just simply didn't play well enough," Dubinsky said. "I think we all underperformed, and we've all taken responsibility and ownership of it and I think have stepped up this year."
Individually, Dubinsky, 30, said he hasn't been as productive as he'd like (10 goals, 26 assists in 66 games), but he attributes that partly to a change in his role. He's being used more in defensive situations and is not playing as much on the power play.
He said that's not something that bothers him.
"You've got to have the right amount of selflessness," Dubinsky said. "To me, I know everyone says it, but it's really all about the team and winning. If you've got to sacrifice some individual successes in order for that to happen, I'm sure everybody would be willing to do that. So I'm just really happy with the way the season is going."
Although the Blue Jackets are comfortably in a playoff spot, they are not satisfied. They trail the Penguins and Washington Capitals by one point for first place in the League standings. Some teams don't pay a lot of attention to the Presidents' Trophy, but the Blue Jackets aren't afraid to say they want it.
"You play ultimately for the playoffs and the Stanley Cup, but the Presidents' Trophy is something you earn because the regular season is 82 games," Dubinsky said. "It's long, it's grueling, it's tough, and it's something we certainly want to go after. … It gives you the opportunity to have home-ice advantage throughout the playoffs. Having played in a number of Game 7s myself, I know how important that home ice can be, especially in those Game 7s. So it's something we're looking after."