Tom Wilson raced into the right wing corner to get to a dump-in ahead of the Columbus defense. Wilson swept the puck around the back of the Columbus cage for Alex Ovechkin, who put a sharp pass out to Matt Niskanen at the opposite (right) point. With Wilson and Kuznetsov providing traffic in front, Niskanen let a shot fly, and Wilson tipped it past Bobrovsky for a 1-0 Washington advantage at 5:552 of the middle period.
The Caps appeared to have doubled that lead to 2-0 when Brett Connolly scored off a goalmouth scramble at 8:09. But the Jackets issued a coach's challenge, alleging that Connolly himself was in the zone ahead of the puck on the play. The subsequent replay confirmed the Columbus theory, and the game remained 1-0.
Just past the midpoint of the middle period, the Jackets tied it up. From deep in his own end, Jackets defenseman Seth Jones fed Artemi Panarin at the center line. Panarin gained the zone on the left side, then went cross-ice for Pierre-Luc Dubois. From the top of the circle, Dubois zipped a wrist shot past Holtby high to the glove side, making it a 1-1 game at 11:18 of the second. The goal was the first of Dubois' playoff career.
When the Jackets ran into some penalty trouble late in the middle frame, the Caps regained the lead. Jakub Vrana drew a slashing call on Columbus center Brandon Dubinsky, and just over a minute later, Jackets defenseman Ryan Murray was also boxed for slashing Vrana, giving the Caps a two-man advantage of 54 seconds in duration. The Caps needed only half of that time to retake the lead.