Winnipeg cut into the Washington lead late in the second, doing so via an imperfect - from the Caps' standpoint - storm of events.
It looked as though Vrana beat a Winnipeg defender to the hash marks in an icing race, but that's not how the zebras saw it, and they blew the whistle for icing. Nicklas Backstrom won the defensive-zone draw, but Michal Kempny's clearing pass hit a skate and caromed right to Cody Eakin in the high slot. Eakin had a free shot and he took it, pounding the puck on net. Holtby stopped but did not secure the shot, and Nikolaj Ehlers pulled it off his pad and put it in to make it a 3-1 game at 18:33.
"I liked the start to our game," says Caps coach Todd Reirden. "I liked the first half of the game for sure. That was closer to our style. You saw contact from a number of different guys, you saw offensive-zone time, we convert on some plays. We let them back in at the end of the second, and made a couple mistakes there, and they take advantage of it. But some positive things for sure, through that first almost two periods."
Shortly after the Caps' only power play of the game early in the third, Washington turned the puck over on a low-to-high play, sending the always dangerous Kyle Connor in on a breakaway. He beat Holtby to make it a 3-2 game at 8:39 of the third.
Late in regulation, Winnipeg's Mark Scheifele bulled his way to the Washington net with the puck, and with Orlov in tight pursuit. Scheifele lost his footing, and the puck hit Orlov's skate and bounded it with 3:14 left, tying the game at 3-3 and forcing overtime.
Both sides had chances in the extra session, but both goalies were perfect. Washington scored three times in a five-round shootout, and the Caps' captain combined with Holtby to put a coda on his big night. Ovechkin scored in the fifth, and Holtby stopped Ehlers to seal the win.