Jack McBain and Mikhail Sergachev scored, and Clayton Keller had two assists for the Mammoth (22-20-4), who had won three in a row and four of their past five. Vitek Vanecek made 33 saves.
“I think I’m disappointed about the way we process that game, the way our thought process, mindset, our play with the puck, our play without the puck,” Utah coach Andre Tourigny said. “I think [Vanecek] gave us an opportunity to get a point, which is a big point, which is important.”
Pyyhtia gave Columbus a 1-0 lead at 2:47 of the first period, beating Vanecek on the blocker side.
McBain tied it 1-1 at 16:20, deflecting the puck behind Greaves off a shot by Keller.
Sergachev put Utah ahead 2-1 at 1:02 of the second period after beating Greaves with a wrist shot from the point.
“We, I think, gave up a little too much,” Sergachev said. “I don't know what the analytics say, but it felt like we were under siege quite a bit and didn't make the right decisions at the right times, and that was the game.”