Shortly after the midpoint of the first, Oshie struck again to give the Caps a lead. Once again, the Caps struck soon after losing a face-off, but this time the draw was in their end of the ice. Once again it was Josh Brown losing control of the puck, this time at the Washington line. The Caps broke out on a 3-on-2, with Anthony Mantha feeding Oshie for the goal at 11:10, just a dozen seconds after the draw in Washington territory. Rookie Caps center Connor McMichael collected the secondary helper, his first NHL point.
Washington went up 3-1 on a Nick Jensen goal at 13:37. After taking a feed from partner Dmitry Orlov, Jensen crept to the top of the right circle and put a well-placed wrist shot behind Forsberg, his second of the season.
Just over two minutes later, Forsberg's night came to an end. Lars Eller found John Carlson with a cross-ice feed, and Carlson shimmied to shake off a defender before coolly picking the far corner and putting it there at 15:43. Filip Gustavsson came on in relief for Ottawa at that point.
Washington put a lot of rubber on the Ottawa net in the first, but the Caps didn't look strong defensively in the first 20 minutes. The Sens really got rolling in the second, scoring three goals in less than five minutes to erase Washington's lead, and evening the score at 4-4.
First, Josh Norris scored a rush goal, taking a fine feed from Artem Zub and cranking a one-timer past Samsonov from the bottom of the right circle at 5:57. Chris Tierney made it 4-3 on an Ottawa power play at 9:37, scoring from the top of the paint to bring the home team within one. And at 11:16, Batherson was parked in front when Carlson's clearing bid bounded off Brady Tkachuk and came right to him; he buried it for his second of the night.
While the Sens were pouring those three pucks into the Washington net, they were also holding the Caps without a shot on net for more than nine minutes.
But late in the period, the Caps battled back to restore and then extend their lead. First, Alex Ovechkin blocked a Nikita Zaitsev shot, creating a breakaway for himself in the process. He beat Gustavsson while holding his broken stick together; he busted the twig blocking the Zaitsev shot.