The Blues would strike again before the period was over with a power play goal of its own. Brayden Schenn banked a pass of Lundqvist from below the goal line that found its way in under the crossbar to give St. Louis the 2-1 advantage.
Despite 16 shots on goal in the third period, including a shorthanded breakaway by Michael Grabner, New York was unable to solve Hutton, who is 3-0 in four career games against the Rangers. St. Louis iced the game with an empty-net goal with 1:47 remaining.
The Rangers have led in just one game this season, its only win that came on Sunday against Montreal. It all comes back to starts, with Kevin Shattenkirk stating the Blueshirts are trying to do too much off the hop while still trying establish who they are as a team.
"I don't think there's any rhyme or reason to it," said Shattenkirk, who picked up an assist on Zibanejad's goal. "We need to focus early on in making simple plays, getting pucks in their zone, grinding away a little bit. I think we're trying to make it look like an All-Star game out there too early on when we haven't established our identity, which is putting pucks in, going to work. We're good when we play fast all over the ice and we seem to try to just make it too complicated early on."
While the Rangers are just four games into an 82-game schedule, Lundqvist said the time to get things moving in the right direction is now.
"It's important that we get the urgency and realize how important the next game is and the game after that," said Lundqvist, who made 20 saves. "You have to see it as a big game every night. It's going to be a tight race this year and if you want to be in it, when it comes down to it, you have to ready now even though it's October."