Cale Makar, Defenseman, Colorado Avalanche
Makar was a frontrunner in preseason Calder forecasts and his early fast start doesn't deter. He leads all rookies six points as a defenseman. He plays on a powerplay unit with Nathan McKinnon, actually "quarterbacking" or initiating the man-advantage puck movement to create the highest quality scoring chances. That powerplay unit includes Colorado captain Gabriel Landeskog and rising scorer Mikko Rantanen. No first-year defenseman has scored more than 50 points since 193. Makar will likely flood that drought.
Kaako Kappo, Right Wing, New York Rangers
The 18-year-old Finn scored his first NHL goal over last weekend. There will be many more. He might be the most NHL-ready rookie this season despite not playing in the league until this month. In contrast, Makar (listed above) played 10 playoff games last spring and defenseman Quinn Hughes (below) worked the blue line for Vancouver for five regular-season games. Here's why: While Makar and Hughes starred for college teams, Kappo scored a lot against grown men in the respected SM-liiga the Finnish elite pro league. Kappo, the No. 2 overall pick in the NHL Draft last June, is 6-3, 190 pounds, physical enough to take hits and give some. He will score plenty this season on the second line and even more if he gets to play with NYR's scoring machine free-agent signee, Artemi Panarin, on the first line.
Quinn Hughes, Defenseman, Vancouver Canucks
Hughes is another "puck-mover" on defense with a mindset that positions him as a team leader for many seasons ahead. He is the prototype-along with Makar-for what you might call an undersized defenseman but you would be forgetting the NHL has become a speed game. Hughes will do his job defensively to shut down the flotilla of hyper-fast skaters in the Western Conference while helping boost Vancouver's scoring. There's a reason why he leads all rookies in the time-on-ice (TOI) category at 20 minutes. TOI is a major indicator of a coaching staff's confidence in a player to defend at critical times, create scoring chances when the situation beckons or, in Hughes' case, both.
Victor Olofsson, Buffalo Sabres
Here is the early scoring leader among NHL rookies with five goals and two assists. He led the Swedish pro league in goals two seasons ago, then notched 30 in 66 American Hockey League goals last season, finishing the year with the Sabres (two goals in six games). New coach Ralph Krueger has paired Olofsson with first-line center and 22-year-old captain/Buffalo savior Jack Eichel. That is why Oloffson gets a top contender nod.