Although possession metrics were fairly even after 40 minutes, the Caps could have had an advantage in that department had they been able to manage the puck better. Washington put on late surges in each of the first two periods, but wasn't able to solve Jackets goalie Joonas Korpisalo.
Holtby and Pheonix Copley were able to keep the Caps within a goal, and Copley made a critical stop on Jackets winger Lukas Sedlak on a semi-breakaway midway through the third to keep the deficit at one, giving Washington a chance to pull a point late.
With Copley pulled for an extra attacker and just over a minute remaining in regulation, the Caps took advantage of Columbus icing the puck. Nicklas Backstrom won a left dot draw, and the Caps worked the puck around the top of the umbrella to Evgeny Kuznetsov, who blasted a one-timer past Korpisalo to square the score at 1-1 with 66 seconds left.
With Backstrom boxed for slashing in overtime, Jackets winger Artemi Panarin won it for Columbus with a one-timer on the power play. But given that they spent the night chasing the game and trying to spark some offense, and that they had to make and abrupt goaltending change mid-game, the Caps have to be pleased to pull the point. Without Copley's save on Sedlak and Kuznetsov's well placed one-timer, it doesn't happen.
"I mean, yeah," says Caps center Nic Dowd. "It's good teams and it's the time of year where you have to find different ways to win. We're not going to beat teams 5-0 like we did earlier in the season, and we have a target on our back as well, too. I think we did a good job of grinding back. We outshot them and we had a little bit of some weird stuff happen with Cops coming in late, and he played really well. We've just got to find more ways to create a little bit of offense."