As it had done in the first, Washington killed off a second straight Philadelphia power play in the second and the Capitals were 62 seconds shy of getting to the room with that one-goal lead. That's when Philly's Shayne Gostisbehere and Washington's Justin Williams were sent off for hi-sticking and slashing, respectively.
The call on Williams was a weak one; he merely lifted Gostisbehere's stick, but the official bought it and sent both players to the box instead of the Caps having what would have been their first power play of the night.
Some 40 seconds later, the Flyers tied the game again. After Holtby made an excellent stop on Philly defenseman Ivan Provorov, Kuznetsov collected the puck out of the corner and attempted to send it out of the zone indirectly, off the boards. But the puck took a Philadelphia bounce, kicking right out to the middle of the ice where Claude Giroux was able to collect it and quickly fire it past Holtby to make it a 2-2 game with 20.7 seconds left in the second period.
Both sides had chances in the third, but both goaltenders were at their best, as each made two or three excellent stops to deny strong scoring chances. When Tom Wilson was finally able to draw a power play for the Capitals with 1:48 remaining, Washington had a chance to take the lead once more. Mason stopped Caps captain Alex Ovechkin from the doorstep with seconds remaining, and Jakub Vrana wasn't able to get a stick on the rebound.
Matt Niskanen nearly won it for Washington as time ticked down in the extra session, but Mason was able to kick up his left pad to deny what appeared to be a vacant upper half of the net.
"[Niskanen] came across and it was kind of a little scorpion kick," says Mason. "It was a desperation thing to take as much of the upper portion of the night away. I had a pretty good portion of the ice covered with my leg, I was just trying to get some of the vertical stuff going."
"I was going to get a shot off but obviously I don't have a ton of experience being one-on-one with the goalie like that," says Niskanen. "I tried my best to go across and find an opening but not much of my game there."
A fun game between a pair of longtime rivals who faced one another in the playoffs last spring didn't deserve a shootout, but it got one anyway, because those are the rules. Philly prevailed in that portion of the evening's activity to pull the extra standings point.
"Anytime you play one of your main rivals, it always emulates a playoff game," says Philly forward Wayne Simmonds. "It's pretty intense. We knew at any moment any mistake their team can capitalize on. I think it was a great game by both teams."