When Hathaway drew a slashing call on New York's Brett Howden with 9.2 seconds left in the second, the Caps power play went to work for the fourth time on the night, seeking the equalizer. But Washington's extra-man unit was blanked on its four opportunities in Thursday's game, ending a streak of five straight games with at least one power-play goal.
The Caps were able to generate more heat in the attack zone in the third, but while pressing hard for the tying tally, they ended up digging the hole a little deeper.
When a Jakub Vrana-to-T.J. Oshie pass failed to click deep in New York ice, it gave the Rangers possession and left all three Washington forwards below the dots along with Zdeno Chara, who had pinched down the left half-wall. The result was a 2-on-1 rush with a trailer for the Rangers, and when Caps defenseman Trevor van Riemsdyk -- the lone man back for Washington -- wasn't able to succeed in a desperate dive to knock the puck off Strome's stick, it left the New York center with an easy lay-up at 7:55, following a quick exchange with Artemi Panarin.
"For me, as the game pushed on, I thought we got better," says Caps coach Peter Laviolette. "But as you're starting to press, also you leave yourself a little bit vulnerable for what's coming against you as you try to score and tie things up."
Strome's second of the night proved to be the game-winner. The Caps pulled to within a goal on Ovechkin's marker, but weren't able to pull even. Pavel Buchnevich scored into an empty net to account for the 4-2 final.
The outcome leaves the Caps with consecutive losses and the Rangers with consecutive victories, each for the first time this season.