Coming into the series, the Avalanche knew they'd have their work cut out for them against the two-time defending champions. And with two of the four previous games in the Final having required overtime, it was no surprise that it was a difficult challenge to close out the Lightning in Game 5 on Friday.
Colorado had tied up the score 2-2 early in the third period and both teams were dialed in as the Avalanche looked to pull ahead in what would have clinched the Stanley Cup for them, while the Bolts were inspired to keep their season alive.
At 13:38, the Bolts restored their lead with the game-winner and the goal to force a Game 6 back in Tampa. Their top line executed a slick passing sequence and their two defenseman joined in. After grabbing a slot from Mikhail Sergachev and positioned in the right faceoff circle, Victor Hedman threaded a pass into the slot for Palat, where the Tampa winger zipped his low shot shortside and past Kuemper to give the Bolts a 3-2 lead.
From the get-go the game featured a tight-checking back-and-forth flow from both sides. The Bolts eventually recorded the game's icebreaker at 15:21.
The Avalanche - who led the frame with a 13-11 shot advantage - had killed off consecutive penalties early on as J.T. Compher went to the box for hi-sticking at 3:13 and Nazem Kadri was assessed for hooking at 6:58. Colorado received a power play of their own at 11:17, but failed to convert.
Shortly after, Tampa Bay found the back of the net with a chance in transition. Corey Perry zipped a cross-ice pass to Rutta, who jetted into the Avalanche's zone. The Bolts defenseman unleashed a 95 mile-per-hour clapper that hit off Kuemper and under his elbow to give Tampa Bay a 1-0 lead.
Colorado nearly equalized the score with one minute left in the game as Devon Toews sprung Nathan MacKinnon on a breakaway. MacKinnon beat Vasilveskiy five hole, but his shot missed the net wide.
Early in the second period, the Avalanche tied the game up 1-1, but would relinquish a power play goal to trail the middle frame 2-1 heading into the second intermission.