Each team had some notable chances early, with CBJ goalie Joonas Korpisalo having to make two big early stops, denying Blake Comeau just a minute into the game from the doorstep and stopping Rhett Gardner on a breakaway. Dallas' Jake Oettinger also was good early, making a save on Alexandre Texier on a shorthanded 2-on-1.
But the teams did trade goals in the period, starting with Columbus getting on the board at 6:06 with Gavrikov's goal. Atkinson fed Oliver Bjorkstrand at the blue line, with The Maestro deking past Nick Caamano to get into space along the right wing and centering a pass that Gavrikov tipped home from the top of the crease to make it 1-0.
Dallas had the response at 12:35, as captain Jamie Benn got on the board. John Klingberg flipped a puck from the neutral zone on Korpisalo, who fought off the bouncing puck only to see Benn follow the play and bat the rebound into the net to tie the score at 1.
The Stars then took a 2-1 lead just past the midway point of the second, as Denis Gurianov scored at 10:10 to give Dallas the advantage. It came on the rush, as Gurianov fed Benn as the trailer on an odd-man rush, and Benn returned the pass to allow Gurianov to score into the open net past the sprawled Korpisalo from the right circle.
Then, a pair of goals in a 20-second span gave the Stars a 4-1 lead and spelled the end of the night for Korpisalo. First Joe Pavelski tallied on a spinning backhander in the slot on a shot that Korpisalo never saw at 13:14. Moments later, the Stars earned a 2-on-1 after Patrik Laine lost his stick and Andrew Peeke lost his footing, as John Klingberg's centering pass went off the stick of Scott Harrington and through the legs of Korpisalo.
Elvis Merzlikins came into the game in relief of Korpisalo, but Dallas tallied three minutes into his tenure when Esa Lindell made it 5-1 at 16:40, completing a long shift in the CBJ zone by scoring from the slot.
The third period was largely academic, though Eric Robinson did get a good look only to be denied by Oettinger.