After nine seasons as an NHL forward, Nill spent nine as an NHL executive -- three with the Ottawa Senators, six with the Red Wings -- before becoming a GM candidate. The Hanna, Alberta, native was a finalist with the Flames in 2000, but even though he'd helped build championship teams in Detroit in 1997 and '98, he didn't get the job.
Nill spent 13 more years in Detroit, helped build championship teams in 2002 and '08, and kept learning from several Hall of Famers. At one point, Nill committed to stay in exchange for a high salary for an assistant GM. The Red Wings declined requests from multiple teams to speak to him. Later, Nill negotiated an out clause.
The Montreal Canadiens called in 2012. Nill spoke over the phone twice with owner Geoff Molson but declined to pursue the job in large part because of his wife's health. When the Stars called a year later, his wife told him it was time to be a GM.
It has been hard. Three times, the Stars missed the Stanley Cup Playoffs. Twice, they lost to the St. Louis Blues in Game 7 in the second round. Last season, it happened in double overtime, and the Blues went on to win the Cup.
But Nill is here for a reason.
"I remember when I first got into this end of the business," Nill said. "You're young. You're energetic. You're ready to go. You think you can tackle anything. And when I look back now, I had some opportunities maybe to go to other teams when I was younger, probably a good thing I didn't, because I may have got eaten alive.
"It's a tough business. You have to live the ups and the downs. You're dealing with ownership. You're dealing with media. You're dealing with players, with agents. And it's a tough position. And I was very fortunate to be put in the right situations to learn from great people and then to have the opportunity come to Dallas."
Nill inherited pieces like Jamie Benn and John Klingberg, but via the NHL Draft, trades and free agency, he brought in pieces like Ben Bishop, Miro Heiskanen, Roope Hintz, Anton Khudobin, Joe Pavelski, Alexander Radulov and Tyler Seguin.
He went from Lindy Ruff to Ken Hitchcock to Jim Montgomery behind the bench, then fired Montgomery on Dec. 10 for unprofessional conduct and replaced him with Rick Bowness.
"It's not a magic wand," Holland said. "You work and you build and you draft, and now you're seeing the fruits of his labor."
At the same time, his wife has helped give others hope, reaching out to fellow cancer patients, organizing Bible studies for Stars employees and wives. Right now, she's quarantining at home because of the coronavirus, watching the grandkids, rooting for the Stars.
"We've been very blessed," Nill said. "We all know we don't know where our next breath's going to come from, but she lives the right way, treats people right, and she's in a good spot."