Columbus needed less than a minute to respond, getting even on a Patrik Laine goal 41 seconds after the Mantha marker. The Jackets won a draw in their own end, and a dozen seconds later Laine fired a shot past Darcy Kuemper from between the hash marks, tying the game at 10:37.
With Garnet Hathaway in the box for interference, Yegor Chinakhov gave the Blue Jackets their first lead with a power-play goal at 14:58. Chinakhov put a laser of a shot to the far side to make it a 2-1 game.
Less than 90 seconds later, the Caps went to the power play courtesy of a Boone Jenner holding call. Washington was dominant with the extra man, spending most of the two minutes in the offensive zone and constantly creating, but it wasn't able to score.
Not to worry, kid. Jenner came out of the box and went right back in, this time for an unwise slashing violation in the offensive zone. This time, the Caps cashed in. Evgeny Kuznetsov gained the Columbus line on the rush, then slid a pass a cross for Alex Ovechkin. Carlson bumped it onto the captain's blade, and Ovechkin's one-time blast from above the left circle eluded Merzlikins to make it a 2-2 game with 12.7 seconds left in the first.
In the middle frame, the Jackets regained the lead on a Sean Kuraly shot that beat Kuemper on the glove side at 3:25. Nic Dowd squeaked a shot through Merzlikins' pads at 8:34 to knot the game again, and then then penalties started up, again.
Washington missed a chance to retake the lead on a man advantage less than a minute after the Dowd goal, and then the Blue Jackets closed out the period with three straight power play opportunities in a span of less than eight minutes.
Each team had a power play in the third and each team had its share of looks and chances, but the final frame was scoreless and overtime was needed to settle the score. That's when Strome stepped up and made a winner of Kuemper, who stopped 36 of 39 shots he faced on the night.
For the second straight game, Kuemper kept the Caps in the contest early until his teammates could get the offense cranked up.
"It's nice especially in preseason," says Kuemper of seeing, feeling and handling a lot of pucks early in the last two exhibitions. "You want to get some reps and start getting comfortable with different parts of the game. So it's nice to get some work and to see some of those game situations that are harder to replicate in practice, so those were perfect preseason games to be in."