Pittsburgh kept the heat on Holtby in the Washington end throughout the third, a period in which the Pens owned a 16-5 advantage in shots on net and a 32-9 bulge in shot attempts, despite the Caps' advantage in power play time. Holtby walled off everything the Pens sent in his direction, and there was no loose change to be had around the net, either.
Just as the Caps seemed to be clinging to life and angling to eke a point out of a potential overtime game, Oshie returned to action with less than four minutes left.
The Pens played a strong game throughout, but consecutive icing calls in the game's penultimate minute proved to be their undoing. Pittsburgh won both of those defensive zone draws, but iced the puck after the first one and failed to clear the zone after the second.
Evgeny Kuznetsov carried up the left wing wall, leaving the puck for Carlson near the line. Carlson saw enough space to lug it down to the top of the circle, and while Ovechkin was attracting Pittsburgh's attention near the paint, Oshie found a soft spot, and Carlson found Oshie. The Washington winger calmly delivered his karmic shot to the shelf, sending the fans into a frenzy, and sending the Pens home with no points.
"I don't know what to say," says Backstrom of Oshie. "I rarely saw him on the bench there, but he came back at the right time. That's what big players do. They come back, and they score the game-winner."
That game-winner gives the Caps their first modest two-game winning streak of the season, with Oshie supplying the game-winner in both victories.
"I thought our guys played extremely hard," says Pens coach Mike Sullivan. "They deserved a better fate tonight."
He's not wrong. But in hockey, there is occasionally a gulf between what you deserve and what you get. This was one of those nights for both teams.