They dropped seven goals on the defending Stanley Cup champions - four of those coming in a wild, rub-your-eyes-is-this-really-happening third period - and the home side pulled away for a 7-1 win (their 11th in a row) that moved them into the division's top spot, and for the time being, No. 1 position in the NHL.
Yes. You read that right.
Scott Hartnell led the way with a hat trick (his second as a Blue Jacket) and Columbus improved to 22-5-4 on the season; they'll close out the pre-Christmas schedule with a game against the Montreal Canadiens tomorrow night on home ice.
"Quite honestly, I think it was a good process we went through. We were really nervous (at the start)," Tortorella said. "We talked about it between periods. We talked about how we've been playing in this league. That's where they took a big step mentally - they believed they could win."
Here's what we learned:
NO RELENT: The Penguins scored the game's opening goal when Sidney Crosby got behind the Blue Jackets defense and batted his own rebound out of midair only 2:39 into the game. But from that point, it was the Blue Jackets who took control; they were first to pucks, they made the Penguins come the length of the rink to create offense, and they capitalized on opportunities. Perhaps it was an off-night for Matt Murray, who's been so good in goal for the Penguins, but the Blue Jackets smelled blood and put the game out of reach in the third period. Goals from Hartnell, Brandon Saad and Boone Jenner came 51 seconds apart to turn a 3-1 game into a 6-1 rout, and the Blue Jackets closed the door down the stretch.