John Tavares gave Toronto a 1-0 lead at 7:36 of the first period, but the Rangers tied it 1-1 at 8:50 when Filip Chytil scored on a tip-in from the left post off a cross-ice, diagonal pass from Tony DeAngelo.
"We did get a good start, set us up really well … but it's very disappointing that we weren't able to build upon that," Maple Leafs coach Sheldon Keefe said. "Instead, we gave it back, dug ourselves a hole that we just weren't able to get out of."
The Rangers went up 2-1 on Zibanejad's goal at 17:18, a near-side shot from the left circle off a face-off win by Kreider against Matthews. They tied it six seconds later on Kreider's goal off the rush after Zibanejad won the center-ice face-off, also against Matthews.
"The second goal, it's a bang-bang play off a face-off, we'll give them that one," Keefe said. "But then to not be alive and ready right off the drop of the next one, that's just making life real hard on your goalie. We don't like that."
Matthews scored at 16:56 of the second period to cut the lead to 3-2, but Buchnevich scored 34 seconds later, making it 4-2 with a shot that beat Hutchinson, who was unable to settle himself moments after falling down, losing his stick and getting it back.
"The fourth goal is pretty defeating and devastating, frankly," Keefe said. "We need a save there."