The Caps and Coyotes skated to a scoreless first period, with each team failing to cash in on a single power play chance in the initial frame. Holtby made a pair of excellent stops in the immediate aftermath of turnovers by one of his teammates, denying Christian Dvorak from the inside of the left circle early in the first and stopping Lawson Crouse from in tight just over a minute later.
Each team had another opportunity with the extra man early in the second, but again neither team was able to take advantage. Arizona began to tilt the tide of possession in the middle stanza, forechecking the Caps hard and keeping them from getting through neutral ice with any degree of regularity.
The Coyotes scored first, taking a 1-0 lead on a Dvorak goal at 7:06 of the second period. Arizona put together a good shift in Washington ice, and the Caps managed to punch the puck out to the neutral zone at one point, but before they could make a play on it, Coyotes defenseman Alex Goligoski sent Dvorak right back into Washington territory with it. Dvorak left it for Conor Garland up high, and then made a run toward the net. Garland returned it to him, and Dvorak got behind the Caps' defense and tucked it behind Holtby to give the home team the advantage.
Washington was unable to generate much in the way of zone time or scoring chances at 5-on-5 in the middle frame. The Caps went nearly a dozen minutes without a shot on net from a forward, but when they broke that spell late in the period, they also tied the game.