Unfortunately for the Caps, Wilson left the game later in the first period and did not return; he is day-to-day with a lower body injury.
The Caps' power play poured three more shots on Bobrovsky - and had four more blocked - later in the first frame. After killing off the third Washington power play of the first, the Panthers evened the score late in the period.
Sam Bennett pulled a loose puck out of a battle for it in the corner of his own zone, then carried it up ice. As he reached the Washington line, he cut to the middle. From between and just above the circles, he launched a wrist shot between the two Caps defenders and past Vanecek to square the score at 1-1 at 17:55 of the first.
Early in the second, the Panthers took the lead. After the Caps iced the puck, Claude Giroux won a left dot draw, and the puck came to Brandon Montour on the weak side. Montour had all the time and space needed to tee up a drive from the top of the right circle, and Vanecek managed to shoulder that shot aside. But Giroux got a stick on the rebound and directed it in at 43 seconds of the middle period, five seconds after the face-off.
The Caps continued to generate some good looks and strong chances throughout the second, but their finish was lacking, and Bobrovsky made some strong stops as well. The Capitals also kept playing well in all three zones, keeping the Panthers from getting speed through the neutral zone and consistently getting out of their own end without incident, using communal exits when necessary.
In a fine example of Washington's neutral zone sturdiness, the Caps evened the score just ahead of the midpoint of the third. Weegar galloped out from behind his own net, skating swiftly toward his own blueline, only to encounter an Alex Ovechkin pokecheck. Realizing he was in trouble, Weegar kept Ovechkin from getting to the loose puck and taking off on a breakaway, only to watch helplessly as Kuznetsov breezed in and took the breakaway for himself, beating Bobrovsky with a wrist shot to the shelf to forge a 2-2 tie at 8:14.