Just 48 seconds after Hathaway netted his second of the night, Kuraly did the same. He carried into Washington ice, then shimmied around John Carlson to the inside before beating Samsonov with a wrist shot at 8:11 of the second.
A mere 22 seconds later, the game was all even once again. Oliver Bjorkstrand sent Gustav Nyquist into Capitals territory on a breakaway, and the winger neatly tucked a backhander through Samsonov's pads to make it a 3-3 contest at 8:33.
"The second period, I thought we came out and played really good at the start and got a lead," says Laviolette. "And then we just made a couple of mistakes that we typically haven't made. All of a sudden they gained some momentum and then they were pressing, and they hit the post a couple of times."
The Caps and Jackets headed to the third all even, a situation that should have favored the rested Jackets. But Washington didn't display a lack of legs in the third.
With their first power play of the game in the back half of the final frame, the Caps had the Jackets on the ropes; Andrew Peeke was hobbled from eating a couple of Ovechkin shots, and another Columbus defender was playing without a stick. But Carlson's shot went over the net, and the sequence came to a halt when Kuznetsov was boxed for interference.
The Caps killed off the resulting power play and went to work with a couple of good shifts in the attack zone, finally breaking through on Sheary's goal in the penultimate minute of regulation.
After Korpisalo stopped the deflection of Nick Jensen's right point shot, the puck came back out to Jensen, who went across to partner Dmitry Orlov. Orlov took it to center point for a better look, then put it through a wide seam for the lefty-shooting Sheary, who was just below the right dot. The winger settled it and shot it in, all in one motion, sparing the Caps from playing beyond regulation and denying a divisional rival a point.
"There was kind of a scramble in front," recounts Sheary. "Their coverage was a little messed up and once it went up to our [defense], I kind of found a seam and Orly saw me and gave me a nice pass. I had a little bit of time to shoot, so I just tried to get it short side as best as I could. And luckily, it went in."