The Caps kept the heat on, and when Connor McMichael drew a tripping call on Colorado defenseman Sanuel Girard early in the back half of the first, they had a chance to pad their lead on the power play. But instead, a Kuznetsov turnover in neutral ice resulted in a J.T. Compher shorthanded goal at 13:46. Despite their domination, the Caps found themselves all even at 1-1 with the Avs.
Late in the period, the Caps created offense from defense. A multi-player scrum took place in the corner of Washington ice, and when the puck popped out, Tom Wilson bumped it to Nick Jensen, creating a 3-on-1 with Jensen driving the right side, partner Dmitry Orlov in the middle and Alex Ovechkin on the left. Jensen and Orlov worked a give-and-go just inside the Colorado line, and Jensen buried the return from the right circle at 16:53, restoring the Caps' one-goal lead at 2-1.
"You work on a lot of things in practice," says Caps coach Peter Laviolette. "I thought Jens' goal was something we had been working on from a defensive standpoint, about taking guys down; we're stopping them in an area - in a quadrant - and battling and winning the battles. From there, it was a sprint to offense. We were able to catch a puck on the breakout and poke it past and have not one defenseman [on the rush] but two defensemen."
Washington killed off a late Colorado power play and went to the room with that one-goal lead and a whopping 19-5 advantage in shots on net. Colorado had no shots on net after the Compher goal, a span of 6 minutes and 14 seconds.
Early in the middle period, the Avs pulled even again, getting the Caps running around and chasing the puck in their own end. Logan O'Connor carried around the perimeter of the zone, lugging the puck behind the net and up the right half wall before curling to a halt. Meanwhile, Darren Helm got lost on the weak side. O'Connor fed him perfectly, and Helm beat Ilya Samsonov for his first goal as a member of the Avalanche after 14 seasons in Detroit.
Helm's goal came at 3:12, and despite being outshot 20-7 at that juncture, the Avs were all even. Washington killed off an Avs power play minutes later to maintain the status quo on the scoreboard, and Samsonov made one of his best stops of the night just after the midpoint of the middle frame, stepping out to assertively deny O'Connor's bid from just above the paint.
The Caps held the Avs without a shot on net for the rest of the second period, a span of 9:47. When ex-Caps winger Andre Burakovsky turned the puck over in his own end, Lars Eller quickly put it toward the net for Anthony Mantha, who caught it in his skates before scoring from the top of the paint at 14:47 of the second. Mantha's 100th career goal gave Washington its third one-goal lead of the game.