"I think that's exactly the recipe for success for us," says Caps center Lars Eller of his team's diverse attack. "If we get contributions from every line, we're going to be hard to play against and defend against and match up against. I think that was a big part of why we were successful on the road, too."
Pittsburgh had the game's first power play, but it was the Caps that took the lead during the Penguins' man advantage. Garnet Hathaway pokechecked Sidney Crosby in the middle of the Washington zone, sending Tom Wilson up the ice on a 2-on-1 with Martin Fehervary. At the Pittsburgh line, Wilson hit Fehervary with a perfect feed and the rookie defenseman did the rest, ripping a wrist shot past Tristan Jarry on the short side for a 1-0 Caps lead at 4:25 of the first frame.
Just under 10 minutes later, the Caps doubled that lead on a couple of sublime passes that culminated in Hathaway's third goal in two games. From his own end of the ice, Trevor van Riemsdyk sent Alex Ovechkin into Pittsburgh ice along the right-wing wall with a perfectly timed indirect feed. The captain pump-faked a shot before issuing a laser-sharp feed to Hathaway, who one-timed it home from the bottom of the circle on his off wing at 14:05, putting Washington up by a pair.
Caps goalie Vitek Vanecek made a strong stop on Jeff Carter about a minute later, but the Pens began buzzing around the Washington zone in the final minutes of the first, and they got one to go with 80 seconds left. Kris Letang rolled the puck netward, and it got caught in a tangle of traffic in front. Jake Guentzel found it first and potted it, enabling the Pens to halve the Caps' advantage just ahead of the first intermission.
Pittsburgh had a chance to pull even when Connor McMichael was boxed for hooking a dozen seconds into the second, but the Pens' power play slide extended to 0-for-25 when they failed to get even on the man advantage. The Caps were also unable to score on their second power play chance shortly thereafter, but Washington found some late thunder in the middle period, putting some distance between themselves and the Pens going into the third.
Conor Sheary picked off a Brian Dumoulin feed at the Pittsburgh line, and quickly sent Lars Eller back into the zone along the right-wing wall with Daniel Sprong going to the net at the far post. Eller patiently waited before firing the pass across, and Sprong got all of a rolling puck, going to the shelf to beat a sprawling Jarry at 16:11 of the second.