Skip to main content

Subban, Karlsson lead fantasy defensemen rankings

by Brian Metzer

With the 2014-15 NHL season inching closer by the day, has you covered with positional fantasy rankings. Based on Yahoo eligibility, projected lineups, past performance, injury history and each insider's opinion, Matt Cubeta (centers), Matt Sitkoff (left wings), Pete Jensen (right wings), Brian Metzer (defensemen) and Justin Goldman (goalies) bring you up to speed by identifying all the players worth targeting at each position in your upcoming drafts.

By nature, defensemen are designed to prevent teams from scoring goals, but a subsect of the gene pool has seen their DNA evolve. This group is just as adept at rolling up offense as it is in preventing it.

One of the evolved, Alec Martinez, scored the Stanley Cup winning goal for the Los Angeles Kings less than three months ago. The good news is that it's time to regroup and reload for another trip up the mountain towards fantasy glory. That trip gets a lot easier when properly utilizing a defenseman and this should help you gain a better understanding of who you should target.

In putting together these pre-season rankings, we looked back at goals, assists, points, power-play points, plus-minus and shots on goal over a three-season span to better assess who is on the rise and who is on the decline.

The results were interesting in that no defenseman finished in the top 10 in all six standard scoring categories; however four of them, Erik Karlsson (Ottawa Senators), Dustin Byfuglien (Winnipeg Jets), P.K. Subban (Montreal Canadiens), and Keith Yandle (Arizona Coyotes) finished in the top 10 of five of them. fantasy insider Brian Metzer says P.K. Subban should be the first defenseman off the board on draft day. (Photo: Getty Images)

Of those four, Subban and Karlsson slot one and two in our rankings and should be among the first defensemen selected in your league. Shea Weber of the Nashville Predators ranked in only four of the categories, but his team improved offensively, which helped him edge Byfuglien for the No. 3 spot. But do not forget that the latter will qualify as both a defenseman and a right wing in Yahoo Standard leagues.

You should also pay close attention to the next tier featuring guys such as Yandle, who ranked third in shots on goal with 567 over the past three seasons, Kris Letang (Pittsburgh Penguins), who ranked second only to Karlsson in points per game over that span, and of course Drew Doughty (Los Angeles), who isn't far removed from staking a claim to a spot in our top three.

Mark Giordano (Calgary Flames), who scored .73 points per game over 64 games last season, is also extremely valuable, but only if he stays healthy. Mark Streit (Philadelphia Flyers) logged the ninth-highest point total over the past three seasons with 118, and Brian Campbell (Florida Panthers) managed to finish in the top 10 in points, assists and power-play points over that stretch.

Matt Niskanen, Christian Ehrhoff and Michael Del Zotto found new homes in Washington, Pittsburgh and Philadelphia respectively, which could help all three of them build upon past successes or, in the case of Del Zotto, find new ones.

It seems it's mentioned on a yearly basis, but it is probably safe to say that the first defenseman in a 10-team standard league will come off the board during the second round, and it's a good idea to acquire at least one of the top-five defensemen during the first three rounds.

You should also hope to have two defensemen selected by the seventh round. Grabbing a defenseman every three or four rounds helps keep your production evenly distributed throughout your lineup and prevents you from scouring for options in the final rounds.

MOCK DRAFT: Results, analysis of's 12-team, 16-round simulation

RANKINGS: Top 50 breakdown | Center | Left Wing | Right Wing | D-men | Goalies

SLEEPERS: Cubeta | Jensen | Sitkoff

NOTE:'s fantasy staff has determined that the primary position of the players listed below is defense. Each of these players is D-eligible in Yahoo leagues. These are Brian Metzer's defenseman rankings and may not reflect the order of's aggregate top 275 overall fantasy rankings.

Rank Team Player
1. P.K. Subban
2. Erik Karlsson
3. Shea Weber
4. Dustin Byfuglien*
5. Duncan Keith
6. Alex Pietrangelo
7. Keith Yandle
8. Kris Letang
9. Ryan Suter
10. Victor Hedman
11. Drew Doughty
12. Oliver Ekman-Larsson
13. Kevin Shattenkirk
14. Ryan McDonagh
15. Mark Giordano
16. Zdeno Chara
17. Brent Burns*
18. Brent Seabrook
19. James Wisniewski
20. Christian Ehrhoff
21. Andrei Markov
22. Torey Krug
23. Niklas Kronwall
24. Cam Fowler
25.  Jason Garrison
26. Matt Niskanen
27. Jacob Trouba
28. Justin Schultz
29. Slava Voynov
30. Alex Goligoski
31. Brian Campbell
32. Andrej Sekera
33. John Carlson
34. Jay Bouwmeester
35. Dan Boyle
36. Cody Franson
37. Marek Zidlicky
38. Tyson Barrie
39. Mark Streit
40. Jake Gardiner
41. Matt Carle
42. Paul Martin
43. Jack Johnson
44. Dion Phaneuf
45. Dennis Wideman
46. Mike Green
47. Olli Maatta
48. Tobias Enstrom
49. Erik Johnson
50. TJ Brodie
51. Alec Martinez
52. Alexander Edler
53. Roman Josi
54. Hampus Lindholm
55. Tyler Myers
56. Justin Faulk
57. Dougie Hamilton
58. Jake Muzzin
59. Marc-Edouard Vlasic
60. Seth Jones
Just missed: Andy Greene, Kevin Bieksa, Nick Holden, Morgan Rielly, Aaron Ekblad, Danny DeKeyser, Michael Del Zotto, Sami Vatanen, Eric Gelinas, Nick Leddy

*Player has dual-position eligibility in Yahoo leagues

View More

The NHL uses cookies, web beacons, and other similar technologies. By using NHL websites or other online services, you consent to the practices described in our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service, including our Cookie Policy.