Staples in the Stanley Cup Playoffs
Since 2005-06, at least one of the Penguins or Capitals has qualified for the Stanley Cup Playoffs 19 times (including 2026 after Crosby and PIT clinched Thursday). That span includes 13 years in which both Crosby and Ovechkin played in the postseason (there were 14 seasons with both PIT & WSH in the playoffs, but Crosby did not play in the 2011 SCP).
The winner of their four head-to-head series has gone on to win the Stanley Cup each time: Crosby in 2009, 2016 and 2017, followed by Ovechkin in 2018. Across their 25 head-to-head playoff games, only once were both players held off the score sheet (Game 2 of 2016 R2). They combined for 63 points across those games (Crosby: 13-17—30; 13-12 record, 3 series wins; Ovechkin: 15-18—33; 12-13 record, 1 series win).