DETROIT – It’s a job that Joe McDonnell wasn’t sure he’d like, but 18 years later, the former Ontario Hockey League coach of the year can’t imagine doing anything else.
“I was actually still looking to continue on coaching, but then this opportunity came up with Detroit,” said McDonnell, the Wings’ director of amateur scouting. “I wasn’t really sure that I wanted to do it. I never thought about it at all, but they gave me the opportunity and I fell in love with the job as soon as I started.”
For the first time since signing on with the Original Six franchise in 1995, the former NHL defenseman – whose playing career was cut short by a back injury – will be the lead architect and decision-maker for the Red Wings at this Sunday’s NHL draft in New Jersey.
McDonnell’s ascension at the draft table was necessitated when longtime assistant general manager Jim Nill announced in April that he, unlike the Red Wings, was staying in the Western Conference as the new general manager of the Dallas Stars.
While Nill’s departure left a huge hole in the Wings’ front office, general manager Ken Holland is confident in the abilities of McDonnell (pronounced MAC-duh-nell) and Ryan Martin, the club’s assistant GM of hockey administration. Last month, Holland made the decision to not hire a replacement. Instead, Holland split Nill’s old duties with McDonnell handling the annual amateur draft, and Martin running the daily operations of player development in Grand Rapids.
“For me to go outside it’s not fair to the people that have done the work so I’m going to spread out the responsibility to the people that have been here,” said Holland at the time of his decision. “I believe we have a pretty good program going. … Joe McDonnell and our amateur scouts will run the draft and I hope they all want to stay, but I’m not going to hold anyone against their will.”
For two decades, McDonnell and European scouting director Hakan Andersson have had tremendous input with the Wings’ draft, funneling player recommendations to Nill, who orchestrated the team’s annual efforts. Even though Nill was introduced to the Dallas media on April 29, the process for this year’s draft was complete.
McDonnell, as well as Nill prior to his departure, evaluated hundreds of draft-eligible players from Western Canada to faraway hockey outposts like Sochi, Russia preparing for Sunday’s draft, which is considered the deepest collection of amateur hockey talent in the last decade. But with young defensemen still in their early 20s – Brendan Smith, Danny DeKeyser, Brian Lashoff, Ryan Sproul, Xavier Ouellet, Mattias Backman, Nick Jensen and Alexei Marchenko – in the system, the Red Wings would like to use their No. 18 overall pick on a forward, someone like Rimouski’s Frederik Gauthier or Russian winger Andre Burakowsky.
However, trades or other developments could affect the Red Wings’ thinking while on the Prudential Center floor, said McDonnell, who played and later coached for the Kitchener Rangers.
“We would really like to get a forward, and this year seems to be a real good year to need a forward,” he said. “Having said that, if we’re picking 18 and there are four or five quality defensemen that we have rated quite high and they’re sitting there when we’re picking we’ll go that route. It’s all a matter of putting assets into the system and preferably this year a forward, but if one of those real good defensemen that we’re really, really high on is sitting there we’ll take him.”
Unlike drafts in other North American pro sports where first-year players are selected for immediate impact, the NHL draft, for the most part, is about developing prospects, whose final grade is typically years away.
“For the most part, I think you’re looking at perhaps a three or four year process with these kids,” McDonnell said. “There are no guarantees for any of them, and we’re taking kids at 18 years of age and you really don’t know what their true character is, or if they’re really willing to put the time or effort into becoming a pro athlete or not.”
What McDonnell does known though, is that the Red Wings won’t land one of the perceived NHL-ready prospects in this draft as defenseman Seth Jones and forwards Nathan MacKinnon, Jonathan Drouin and Alesander Barkov will be long gone before Detroit picks.
“Other than the top guys like Seth Jones, I think the 40th (ranked) player could go 10, 11, or 12,” McDonnell said. “It’s really beauty in the eye of the beholder.”
Below is a short sampling of who the Red Wings might select in the first round on Sunday:
WHO TO TAKE AT NO. 18?
|Robert Hagg |
ROBERT HAGG, defenseman, Modo Jr. (SWE)
A 6-foot-2 left-handed shooter, Hagg was the captain on Sweden’s 2013 World Junior Championship team that lost to the U.S. in the gold medal game. He split last season between Modo’s Swedish Elite League club and its U20 team, where he was named the top U20 Super Elit defenseman of the year. According to the NHL’s Central Scouting, he was the No. 7 ranked European skater last season. He is also the younger brother of forward Christian Hagg, who has played the last three seasons in the Swedish Elite League.
McDONNELL’S TAKE: “He’s got a booming shot from the point. He works the power play real, real well and I guess one the biggest things that we’ve learned about the kid, in doing our background checks, is that he’s a high-quality kid and he’s a leader."
SHEA THEODORE, defenseman, Seattle (WHL)
The 6-foot-2 Langley, B.C., native has won three gold medals, including two with the Canadian U18 team at the 2012 Ivan Hlinka Memorial tournament and the 2013 U18 World Championship in Sochi, Russia with likely follow NHL draftee Josh Morrissey. Theodore showed tremendous improvement last season, finishing eighth among all Western League defensemen in scoring with 19 goals and 31 assists.
McDONNELL’S TAKE: “From all indications that we’ve heard, he seems to be a team leader and is a very explosive skater. He lugs the puck out of his own end really well. It sure doesn’t hurt to play on a winning team, like a kid in our system in Tomas Jurco, who won a Memorial Cup and now he’s won a Calder Cup. Winning is invaluable for the confidence of these kids at this level.”
FREDERIK GAUTHIER, center, Rimouski (QMJHL)
VIDEO SCOUTING REPORT
This 6-foot-5, 210-pound forward is perhaps the best two-way player eligible for this weekend’s draft. He can play all three forward positions, and finished as the fourth leading scorer among first-year players in the Quebec league producing 22 goals and 38 assists in 62 games. NHL Central Scouting ranked him as the No. 8 best North American skater. He represented Canada in the 2013 U18 World Championship, collecting a goal, three assists and a gold medal.
McDONNELL’S TAKE: “He was outstanding in the gold medal game at the April tournament overseas. He seems like a real quality two-way player who can play whatever way you want. He’s a guy too who is coming right out of midget into the Quebec league, so he took a big step and did very, very well in his first year in that league.”
JOSH MORRISSEY, defenseman, Prince Albert (WHL)
VIDEO SCOUTING REPORT
Was second among league rookie defensemen in 2011-12 with 38 points in 68 games, and finished 12th among blueliners in scoring this season with 47 points, including 15 goals, in 70 contests. He was named the 2013 Canadian Hockey League’s scholastic player of the year. He helped Canada win the gold medal in the 2013 U18 World Championship, earning post-tournament recognition as one of Canada’s top three players for leading all defensemen in scoring with three goals and four assists in seven games.
McDONNELL’S TAKE: “He’s not the biggest guy in the world, but he plays bigger than what he is. He’s a real competitor with an excellent skill level to go with it.”
ANDRE BURAKOWSKY, left wing, Malmo (SWE)
An agile, strong skater, this 6-foot-1 forward has a solid offensive acumen. While most of his recent Redhawks career has been spent in Sweden’s second league, he has played 53 games in the Swedish Elite League, producing four goals and eight assists. Born in Austria, he is No. 6 on Central Scouting’s list of European skaters. He was a third-round pick, No. 103 overall, by St. Petersburg in the KHL draft. His Russian father, Robert, was drafted by the New York Rangers in 1985 and played 23 games with the Ottawa Senators, though much of his playing career was spent in Europe.
McDONNELL’S TAKE: “He’s actually a Russian player, whose father moved to Sweden to play years ago. He has a typical high-end Russian skill level. His ceiling is very high with the amount of skill that he possesses.”
BO HORVAT, center, London (OHL)
A Red Wings’ fan while growing up in London, the OHL’s most-valuable player in the 2013 playoffs, he scored a league-leading 16 goals in 21 postseason games for the Knights, including a thrilling game-winner with one-tenth of a second left in Game 7 of the championship series that lifted London to its second straight Memorial Cup. He finished the regular season with a team-best 17 power-play goals. He also represented Canada in the 2012 Ivan Hlinka Memorial tournament with fellow draft prospect and London teammate Max Domi.
McDONNELL’S TAKE: “He’s played in two straight Memorial Cups and will play in a third one next year. So he’s coming from a winning background. He’s a real character two-way guy, a guy that you love to have on the ice whether you’re down a goal or up a goal. He seems to be a real good team guy.”
J.T. COMPHER, left wing, NTDP (USHL)
The Illinois native is the grandson of former University of Michigan basketball player Richard Meyer (1958-60). Compher will follow in his grandfather’s footsteps as he is committed to play hockey at Michigan in the fall. Compher scored 42 points in 49 games last season in the United States Hockey League for the USA National Development team.
TYLER BERTUZZI, left wing, Guelph (OHL)
The nephew of Red Wings forward Todd Bertuzzi, he's a 6-foot, left-handed shot that could be drafted on Sunday. In two OHL seasons, Tyler Bertuzzi produced 19 goals, 20 assists and 185 penalty minutes in 104 games. Central Scouting projects him as a seventh-round pick.
ERIC COMRIE, goalie, Tri-City (WHL)
He’s the second-highest rated North American goalie by Central Scouting, finishing among the top 10 league netminders, producing a 20-14-1 record with a 2.62 GAA and .915 save percentage for the Americans last season. He is the half-brother of former NHL players Mike and Paul Comrie. Mike is the one married to Hilary Duff.
ANTHONY MANTHA, right wing, Val d’Or (QMJHL)
He led the Quebec league and tied for second in the Canadian Hockey League with 50 goals in 67 games. He isn’t related to former NHL journey defenseman Moe Mantha, but he is the grandson of four-time Stanley Cup champion Andre Pronovost, who played 556 games for Montreal, Boston, Detroit and Minnesota between the 1956-57 and 1967-68 seasons.
Follow Bill Roose on Twitter | @Bill_Roose