"He's been great for us all season long," defenseman Cody Ceci said on Sunday. "He's won us a lot of games, and tonight he gave us a chance. There were a few times where they could have ended it and made some big saves, so he was a key part of our team. We're not worried about him. He's a great player, and he's going to be there for us next game."
As it turns out, they were right.
Jarry produced a phenomenal performance on Tuesday at PPG Paints Arena, stopping 37 shots in Pittsburgh's 2-1 victory that evened the series at one game apiece.
"Jars is a gamer," winger Bryan Rust said. "He comes to the rink, works hard, learns from the past and moves on. He's an unbelievable goalie. He's showed it time and time again over the course of this year, last year, and he was obviously great tonight too."
The 26-year-old earned his first career playoff victory, was named the game's No. 1 star and got handed the player of the game helmet from fellow netminder Maxime Lagace.
"That's his game," defenseman Mike Matheson said of the NHL All-Star. "That's what we expect from him. I don't think it was anything out of the ordinary for him, as crazy as that sounds. He plays at such a high level. For us to call that his 'norm' is pretty impressive and a testament to how good of a goalie he is."
Jarry didn't see a ton of action right away, as the Penguins came out flying and went up 1-0 less than four minutes in on a goal from Rust. But the Islanders pushed as the game went on, and his first big series of stops came following Jeff Carter's tally to keep the score 2-0.
Nick Leddy fired the puck towards the net, but it was knocked out of danger before it could reach Jarry. Scott Mayfield knocked it out of the air and back towards Jarry, and Casey Cizikas redirected it. Jarry made an incredible save on that attempt, then again seconds later on Cizikas' rebound try.
At that point, the "JARRY! JARRY!" chants filled PPG Paints Arena for the first of many times throughout the course of the evening.
"It's awesome," Jarry said. "It's exciting. It's exciting to hear them and you know how passionate our fans are and how much they get into the game. I think that's awesome. We love to see it. We love when they're behind us like that."