"It was a game of basically less than inches," Panthers coach Joel Quenneville said. "With the opportunities at the end, we did some good things. Their goalie made some key saves. Some of [our looks] there around the net, if we could've buried some it could've been the difference."
Mathew Barzal opened the scoring for the Islanders, beating Sergei Bobrovsky with a backhand shot from near the low slot to put the Panthers in a 1-0 hole at 5:40 of the first period. After that, the teams were locked into a defensive battle, with neither lighting the lamp for over 40 minutes.
At 6:12 of the third period, Aleksander Barkov batted in a loose puck past Thomas Greiss from the doorstep to make it a 1-1 game. But just 38 seconds later, Scott Mayfield sent a shot toward Florida's net that bounced off two defenders before going in to put New York ahead 2-1 at 6:50.
Then, with roughly five minutes left to play, the game took a controversial turn.
With the Panthers on the power play, Barkov appeared to tie the game when he knocked a puck off Mayfield and into the net. Initially, the call on the ice was that it was a good goal. Soon after, however, it was overturned after officials deemed the puck had been touched with a high stick.
Upon further review, the secondary "no-goal" call was upheld.
"You could argue that one," Panthers coach Joel Quenneville said of the sequence." Whatever call was going to be on the ice was going to be on the call. It originally was [good]. It's tough."
While the Panthers had a handful of good scoring chances in the final minutes of regulation, Greiss stood tall to secure the 2-1 win and help the Islanders extend their point streak to 12 games. Winning his sixth straight game, he turned aside 37 of 38 shots that came his way.
At the other end of the ice, Bobrovsky looked just as good while stopping 34 of 36 shots.
"He made some great saves all alone, a couple there at the end as well," Quenneville said of Bobrovsky. "He gave us a chance. Their goalie had one of those nights as well. It was one of those nights where goaltending was outstanding. The chances were pretty high-quality today."
Despite the loss, Florida (7-4-5) has earned at least one point in 11 of its last 13 games.
Here are five takeaways from Saturday's loss in Brooklyn…