"This is what we can do when we play a consistent, hard game," said Scheifele, who has at least one point in each of the Jets' first three games. "It was against a good team tonight and we battled the adversity when they scored two goals.
"There was some anxiety, yes, losing the last two games, but for the most part we handled the adversity and did better after that."
The Jets finish their three-game road trip against the Vancouver Canucks on Thursday (10 p.m. ET, TSN3, SNV, NHL.TV).
Their outlook for that game will not be significantly different, defenseman Jacob Trouba said.
"This proves nothing," said Trouba, who played a game-high 26:50 on Monday. "There wasn't any panic before. We lost two games. There may be bigger losing streaks than that, and maybe winning streaks too. I don't think there was too much angst. We just made an effort to keep a level head in that third period, something we need to keep doing."
Maurice singled out the defense pair of Trouba and Josh Morrissey, which also spent most of its time matched against McDavid's line Monday and said Scheifele's line was strong defensively as well as offensively.
"How they get the puck from our end to their end, it was simple," Maurice said. "They cut pucks off, got pucks deep and made real good decisions. [Scheifele] backchecked … and those are important things from a leadership point of view. That's as good a game as I've seen him play."
Scheifele, who finished seventh in the League last season with 82 points (32 goals, 50 assists) in 79 games, said consistency, not one-game excellence, is the most important thing ahead.
"Our line felt good, but it has to be every night," he said. "It was a fun night with those two. Maybe it will be something consistent we'll get going."