Trotz earned 93 points, 30 more than Jon Cooper, who won 62 games with the Tampa Bay Lightning. Bill Peters, who coached the Calgary Flames to first place in the Pacific Division and the Western Conference, was third with 52 points.
"I don't think there was a lot of expectations on the Islanders; everybody thought we would fold," Trotz said. "The people that are in the organization, be it the players, obviously the management and the structure, nobody felt that we couldn't be a pretty competitive team. I think the players' mindset is that people are underestimating us. We came in and said, 'Let's have a really good team game,' and a team game makes up for a lot of things. … Everybody contributes, and that's the strength of our group."
The Islanders do not have a 30-goal scorer -- captain Anders Lee leads them with 28 -- nor do they have anyone close to 100 points. But they've won with defense and goaltending, with Robin Lehner and Thomas Greiss combining for an Islanders-record 11 shutouts. They held the NHL-leading Lightning to five goals in three games (1-1-1), with four coming in one game, and were 2-1-0 against the Maple Leafs outscoring them 11-3.
A team-first concept breeding success isn't a new philosophy, but it was one that had become foreign to the Islanders for too long until this season.
"We talked about this has to be a little bit of a new era, a new standard and a new everything," Trotz said. "Let's do it our way, let's do it right and let's have success. We want to prove we can have success all the time."
Voting totals (points awarded on a 5-4-3-2-1 basis): Barry Trotz, Islanders, 93 points (17 first-place votes); Jon Cooper, Lightning, 63 points (one first-place vote); Bill Peters, Flames, 52 points (two first-place votes); Craig Berube, St. Louis Blues, 45 points (one first-place vote); Rod Brind'Amour, Carolina Hurricanes, 23 points; Rick Tocchet, Arizona Coyotes, 20 points; Bruce Cassidy, Boston Bruins, six points; Travis Green, Vancouver Canucks, four points; Mike Babcock, Maple Leafs; three points; John Tortorella, Columbus Blue Jackets, two points; Claude Julien, Montreal Canadiens, one point; Gerard Gallant, Vegas Golden Knights, one point, Jim Montgomery, Dallas Stars, one point; Todd Reirden, Capitals, one point.