But it was his 200-foot game that was most impressive. Backchecking - or a lack thereof - has been an issue for Toronto, which had allowed 26 goals in its previous five games.
"I thought [Matthews] was real good," Toronto coach Mike Babcock said. "I just thought he skated and he was determined - real good defensively and real good offensively and in the end I thought it was a real positive."
Watching Matthews up close has been an education for center John Tavares, who signed a seven-year, $77 million contract with Toronto on July 1. On the nights Matthews showcases his special combination of will and skill, Tavares said the Maple Leafs are a team to be reckoned with.
"Being around him every day, you understand what makes him a special hockey player," Tavares said. "His ability just to stay on the puck, track it down, when you think it's going the other way, his ability to strip guys and be able to hang onto it, protect it, and use his size, he's so deceptive with his shot or finding the open man. He was a force for us."
At 6-foot-3 and 223 pounds, Matthews has the physical attributes to be exactly that. And although his game often showcases more hustle than muscle, he knows he'll have to get into the dirty areas in front of the net with regularity at playoff time when so-called greasy goals become more prevalent.
Matthews and Tavares once again learned that lesson against the Sabres. Matthews' goal came when Andreas Johnsson's backhand pass deflected off his skate at the edge of the crease and past Sabres goalie Carter Hutton in the second period. Tavares was almost in the same spot when a bouncing puck landed at his skate before the second intermission, leaving him with a tap-in into an open net to put Toronto up 2-1.
"Some dirty goals," Matthews said. "Sometimes you just have to get to the front of the net and it will go off a skate or a shin pad or fall there for you."
Matthews has 200 points (109 goals, 91 assists) in 204 NHL games for the Maple Leafs (44-25-5). His line, which features wings William Nylander (six assists in his past five games) and Johnsson (five points in his past six games) is starting to jell at what he hopes is just the right time.