Even crazier, however, is the fact that despite being born and raised in the Pittsburgh area, Cooley's a huge fan of Washington Capitals captain Alex Ovechkin.
"We went to a lot of Penguins games when I was younger, being from West Mifflin (Pennsylvania), and obviously you can't really dislike Sidney Crosby, he's a great guy," Cooley said. "But to be honest, I was kind of a Capitals fan growing up. I really don't know how it happened, but since I was just a little kid, I've liked 'Ovi.'
"He's one of the best players in the world and I like the way he competes. I try to do some of the things he does in his game and put into my game."
Said Cathy: "I don't think we ever admitted this in public before, but he was so passionate about Ovi and loved him so much that it became contagious, just because of Logan and his love for him, that we all became fans of Ovi ... we may be chased out of Pittsburgh after that comment."
Cooley has an Ovechkin jersey and Fathead wall decal. For the record, he also has a Fathead of Crosby and Chicago Blackhawks forward Patrick Kane.
Rooting for Ovechkin in a household full of Penguins fans wasn't easy.
"I grew up with a lot of Pittsburgh fans and was kind of the only one rooting against them," Cooley said with a grin. "Other than that, it was pretty funny just to be around all the Pittsburgh fans and cheering for different teams."
Cooley is a projected top-three selection in the 2022 draft with an opportunity to one day, perhaps, play with or against his boyhood hockey idols. The Montreal Canadiens have the No. 1 pick, the New Jersey Devils hold the No. 2 selection and the Arizona Coyotes have the No. 3 choice.
Cooley is committed to the University of Minnesota in 2022-23.
"[Cooley] skates so well and closes gaps when he wants to retrieve pucks, and breaks away when he's got the puck," Central Scouting senior manager David Gregory said. "He's very hard to contain, very hard to limit, and he has this brain that processes the game very quickly.