Erik Karlsson, their 22-year-old reigning Norris Trophy winner, underwent surgery Thursday to repair a 70-percent tear in his Achilles. He will be out three to four months, according to Ottawa GM Bryan Murray.
"He's playing 30 minutes a game, a Norris Trophy winner, arguably the best player in the League. It's obviously a big loss -- but like every injury, it's somebody's opportunity," coach paul MacLean said Wednesday night. "We have to find out who that's going to be."
During the final minute of the second period, Matt Cooke came from behind to pin Karlsson against the left-wing boards. Cooke's left skate made contact with the back of Karlsson's lower left leg, leaving Karlsson in obvious pain. He immediately headed to the dressing room.
"With (Karlsson), it seemed like everything was going for him," said defense partner Marc Methot, noting Karlsson's six goals and 10 points in 13 games. "All of the sudden, he gets horrible luck out there. It's one of those injuries that requires a lot of bad luck to get. We're going to be missing him huge back there."
There was no penalty called on the play on Cooke, who has a history of supplemental discipline from the NHL. He was suspended for the final 10 regular-season games and the first round of the Stanley Cup Playoffs for an elbow on the New York Rangers' Ryan McDonough in March 2011.
The NHL's Department of Player Safety reviewed the play and spoke to both general managers before determining there would be no supplemental discipline.
When asked if Cooke intended to injure Karlsson on the play, MacLean said: "That's not up to me to decide."
Added Anderson: "I don't know if it's intent to injure, but I don't know why you would hit somebody like that in that situation. I can't tell if it's intent to injure or not, but it obviously catches Erik really unfortunate, a heel of his skate where we don't have any padding.
Cooke, for his part, called the play "a complete accident
"I was at the end of a shift," Cooke said. "As he took a shot, I went to the corner. Him and I were engaged and he went down screaming. I didn't even know what happened.
"Obviously, I feel terrible about it. I'm not trying to do that, obviously.
Ottawa forward Chris Neil took a double-minor for roughing and a 10-minute misconduct in trying to engage Cooke with 2:06 to play. Cooke also was given a misconduct for the skirmish.
"I was surprised he sucker-punched me, but I wasn't surprised he came and asked me [to fight]," Cooke said. "At that point, I don't feel the need to fight.
"[Karlsson's] playing 30 minutes a game, a Norris trophy winner, arguably the best player in the League. It's obviously a big loss -- but like every injury, it's somebody's opportunity. We have to find out who that's going to be." -- Senators' head coach Paul MacLean
"I mean, I understand that's a team sticking up for their own player. It's part of the game ... I don't know what they thought. I mean, I was trying to hit him, but not [injure Karlsson]."
Teammates stood up for Cooke, who has been with the Penguins for five seasons and helped the Pens win the Stanley Cup in 2009. Cooke played his 900th career NHL game Sunday.
"I don't think he tried to do what he did," Pittsburgh captain Sidney Crosby said. "It was just an accident. There's no intention on Cookey's part to hurt him."
It was clear in a tension-filled dressing room that the Senators didn't necessarily agree. General manager Bryan Murray was overheard angrily saying Cooke's name and telling observers to watch the replay.
"We all know who's involved in it," MacLean said. He then added, "That's just the way it is. Injuries are part of the game. We have to move forward."
"Somebody else is going to get more minutes," Senators captain Daniel Alfredsson said. "We're going to have to find a way, as anybody has to. It's going to make it tougher, but we're going to dig deep and see what we can come up with."