They're watching everything, but it's a group effort, as sometimes it's the assistant coaches or a player that will spot something fishy at ice level - on Friday night Johnny Boychuk tipped off Doug Weight to get the wheels in motion. The refs get the overwhelming majority of zone entries right, but there's no harm in double-checking. The harm comes from being wrong, as now it'll put teams shorthanded.
"Our guys are on it and have done a really good job," Weight said in the days after the Isles got a successful challenge against Montreal. "We're batting close to 1.000 and probably messed up on two where we were upset with the calls, but Matty and Dougie in the trenches do a great job and the guys up top (Assistant Coach Scott Gomez and Goalie Coach Fred Brathwaite), so really I just get word if they think it's offside and I'll look at it quickly on the bench. If I can't tell I have to go with them. That's why you have people you trust."
The Islanders have won three of their four offside challenges this season and two of them - the challenges in Montreal and Carolina - played a big role in each win. What's notable about the challenge in Montreal was that the play occurred nearly a minute before the actual goal was scored. The challenge came as a surprise to everyone in the building, but not the two coaches, who have a healthy skepticism and a keen eye.