"It was a series that could have gone either way," Orpik said. "It was just a couple mistakes that probably cost Washington."
A lot has changed since then; Alex Ovechkin, Nicklas Backstrom and Jay Beagle are the only remaining Capitals who played in that 2009 series. With Orpik, now 35, on their side this time, they're hoping things go their way when they begin their Eastern Conference Second Round series against the Penguins at Verizon Center on Thursday (8 p.m. ET; NBCSN, TVA Sports).
Seeking some stability and experience on their back end, the Capitals signed Orpik and Matt Niskanen on July 1, 2014, after the Penguins allowed both to reach unrestricted free agency. The Capitals gave Orpik, who played 11 seasons in Pittsburgh, a five-year, $27.5 million contract. Niskanen, who was a Penguin for 3 ½ seasons, signed a seven-year, $40.25 million contract.
"When you look back at the blue line, it was an Achilles heel for the Caps," Capitals coach Barry Trotz said. "There were young players playing back there, some inexperience, some guys that were maybe a little bit undersized and there wasn't a complete balance on what you needed. Obviously, getting Brooks and [Niskanen] really solidified the blue line, and then all of a sudden that became a strength for us."
Trotz had been hired by the Capitals about a month earlier and brought in Todd Reirden as one of his assistants after Reirden had been fired by the Penguins. Reirden, who worked with the defensemen in Pittsburgh, was one of the reasons Niskanen and Orpik decided to sign with the Capitals.