"I hope they like me more than (the Chiefs liked) Tim McCracken," Shanahan said with a laugh on Friday after the Red Wings alumni practice at downtown Mattamy Athletic Centre, historic Maple Leaf Gardens in refurbished form. "But hey, it would be a good story."
Such lunacy is never going to happen, thankfully, but all the principals were having fun with the idea on the eve of their outdoor game. Imagine: Shanahan, the head of the Maple Leafs, being smudged along the glass by players wearing the jersey of the very NHL team he leads.
"Not many guys have an off switch, which is a good thing," said legendary Maple Leafs agitator Tiger Williams, unable to suppress a grin as he considered the possibility of mayhem. "We've got to keep everything in the right perspective, but the boys will play hard to win. Even in these kinds of games, it's just the way it is."
The dressing room for Toronto will be the kings of chaos from their day, the blue and white version of the Hanson Brothers, who, combined, spent the equivalent of more than 120 full games in the penalty box.
To borrow the label attached to the fearsome New York Yankees of the 1920s, meet hockey's Murderers' Row, ranked by penalty minutes assessed - 7,214 in total - when they skated and cooled their heels for the Maple Leafs:
Tie Domi, 2,265 minutes; Williams, 1,670; Wendel Clark, 1,535; Bob McGill, 988; Darcy Tucker, 756.
Not exactly choirboys for Detroit on Saturday will be Joey Kocur, 1,963 minutes with the Red Wings, and Darren McCarty, 1,302.
Clark, the inspirational leader of the Maple Leafs, already predicts a team sports psychologist will be the most valuable player by day's end.
"He'll be telling us, 'You guys aren't any good any more!' " Clark said with a laugh.
And then he added: "I think (Shanahan) would feel awesome" if Toronto's alumni vaporized him, "because he'd feel a part of it. But we've never hit a president before, we've never gone that high up the ladder."