"I feel like I didn't do much in the first two games," said Atkinson, who led Columbus with 62 points in the regular season but had none in Pittsburgh. "I kind of let the team down. I needed to be way better. I had good energy in the first period, got on the board. I thought we were rolling."
Werenski made it 3-1 on the power play. After scoring two goals in two games, the Blue Jackets had three in 6:10. Everyone thought they were rolling.
But the Penguins dominated the second. Bryan Rust made it 3-2 at 5:21. Werenski took a puck in the face when a Phil Kessel shot deflected off his outstretched stick blade and flew up under his visor. He fell to the ice in the slot, but the Blue Jackets didn't have possession and the play continued for 10 seconds. As Werenski skated off with a trail of blood behind him, Evgeni Malkin made it 3-3 at 13:25.
Werenski returned in the third with a full shield to cheers. Coach John Tortorella said, to paraphrase, he had guts as big as the building.
"He's a warrior," Blue Jackets captain Nick Foligno said. "I talk about leadership, and you've got a 19-year-old kid showing a ton of leadership right there, of what we are and what we expect in this room. I can't say enough good things about him."
After Guentzel gave the Penguins a 4-3 lead at 11:48 with Dubinsky in the box for cross-checking him, Dubinsky tied the game at 4-4 at 15:11.
But Werenski couldn't return for overtime because he was unable to see out of his right eye, and Dubinsky couldn't bury a chance about seven minutes into overtime. When a rebound popped out to him, he fired as Fleury scrambled over to his left. The puck hit the top of Fleury's mask and went out of play.
"A couple inches left, right or higher, I guess, it goes in the net," Dubinsky said. "But it didn't."
Brutal. Penguins captain Sidney Crosby won a battle down low and sent a slick backhand pass in front, as he does. Guentzel. Game.