Skip to main content

A look at the All-Star rosters

by Shawn P. Roarke
RALEIGH, N.C. -- Nicklas Lidstrom and Eric Staal have made their roster picks for Sunday's NHL All-Star Game presented by Discover (4 p.m. ET, Versus, TSN, RDS).

So how did they do? Where is each one strongest? Weakest? Does either team have an edge?  Here's a look at how the two captains did and what they focused on.


Staal started strong in the drafting process by taking hometown hero (and Carolina teammate) Cam Ward in the first round. It was a good start that was followed by the selection of Henrik Lundqvist in the sixth round and Montreal's resurgent Carey Price in Round 10. Team Lidstrom waited a little longer, taking Tim Thomas of Boston in the fifth round before going back-to-back in Rounds 9 and 10 with Pittsburgh's Marc-Andre Fleury and Jonas Hiller of Anaheim.

Edge -- Team Lidstrom. Even though Team Lidstrom waited longer to address goaltending, it has the clear advantage. First of all, the object of goaltending is to win and Lidstrom picked three of the five goalies atop the wins column this season. In fact, Lidstrom's trio has combined for 72 wins. More impressively, Lidstrom selections are three of the top six in goals-against average, including Thomas, who leads in GAA and save percentage. Also, Hiller is the hottest goalie in the League right now and has faced a League-high 1,462 shots -- not a bad thing in a game that sees goalies face a lot of pucks.


Team Lidstrom has a bit of everything on the blue line. First of all, it has Lidstrom himself, the best all-round defenseman of his generation. There's also a lot of offense in Chicago's Duncan Keith (the first defenseman taken), Nashville's Shea Weber, Atlanta's Dustin Byfuglien, Keith Yandle of the Phoenix Coyotes and Minnesota's Brent Burns. Team Staal went in a bit of a different direction. Yes, there is a good deal of offense on the blue line when you consider the presence of fleet-footed Dan Boyle of San Jose, Pittsburgh's Kris Letang, Washington's Mike Green and Ottawa's Erik Karlsson, the final defenseman taken. But Staal's team also has some defensive grit in Boston's Zdeno Chara and Marc Staal of the New York Rangers, perhaps the two most physical defenders in the game.

-- Team Lidstrom. While the Staal boys do have some defensive grit, Nicklas Lidstrom knows defenseman better than anybody, so he's got to get the nod here. The numbers are sobering. Team Lidstrom owns the top three scoring defensemen in the game in Yandle (44 points), Lidstrom (42) and Byfuglien (41). All told, Team Lidstrom outscores Team Staal, 214 to 168 and -- and, as we all know, this game is all about offense.


Team Staal started out loaded up the middle. Eric Staal, the captain, has 25 goals and 52 points. Alternate captain Ryan Kesler of the Vancouver Canucks, meanwhile is having a career year with 27 goals and 47 points. Staal added Carolina rookie sensation Jeff Skinner to the mix in what might have been the most popular move for the fans in attendance, and also added Colorado's Paul Stastny. Team Lidstrom had to build from scratch at the pivot, but that handicap did not hurt the team in the end. In fact, Lidstrom took six centers -- Vancouver's Henrik Sedin, Chicago's Jonathan Toews, Brad Richards of Dallas, Anze Kopitar of Los Angeles, Tampa Bay's Steven Stamkos and Colorado's Matt Duchene 

Edge -- Team Lidstrom. Lidstrom's six centers are a scary collection of pivots that is more about quality than quantity. Stamkos is the game's top-scoring center (67 points) and Henrik Sedin is only 6 points behind while Richards has 57 points. All three of those centers are outscoring Staal, Team Staal's top-scoring center.

Right Wing

Team Lidstrom was loaded on the right, with alternates Patrick Kane and Martin St. Louis both playing that side. But Lidstrom fortified that position even more by taking Philadelphia's Danny Briere, Minnesota's Marty Havlat and, with the final pick of the draft, Toronto's Phil Kessel. Team Staal answered by taking Columbus Rick Nash, Philadelphia's Claude Giroux, Anaheim's Corey Perry and David Backes of St. Louis.

-- Team Lidstrom. Staal's right wings are certainly the more physical and more defensive of the bunch, especially with the gritty Backes and Giroux, as well as Perry. But, Lidstrom's team again has the edge in offensive output, which figures to be the name of the game on Sunday. Plus, Lidstrom has the best right wing in Mr. St. Louis, who will once again be receiving passes from Stamkos, his regular center.

Left Wing

This could be Team Lidstrom's Achilles heel. Stacked at so many other positions, Lidstrom picked just one natural left wing in Loui Eriksson of the Dallas Stars. Lidstrom has already said he will move Richards, a natural center, to the left side as well. Team Staal, meanwhile, has a full compliment of left wings with Washington's Alex Ovechkin, Vancouver's Daniel Sedin, Chicago's Patrick Sharp and New Jersey's Patrik Elias.

-- Team Staal. Even if Lidstrom had a full complement of left wings, he would lose this battle. Team Staal has the two best in the game right now in Ovechkin and Daniel Sedin. Sharp, in the midst of a brilliant year, is no slouch either. Elias has won two Stanley Cups and is a big-game player through and through. A dominating win for Team Staal.


Edmonton's Taylor Hall won the coin toss and pledged his six-man delegation of rookies to Team Lidstrom. That means Hall, center Derek Stepan of the New York Rangers and Florida right wing Evgeny Dadonov are the forwards who will take part in Saturday's skills competition. They will be joined by defensemen Cam Fowler of Anaheim, Kevin Shattenkirk of Colorado and Oliver Ekman-Larsson of Phoenix. Team Staal answers with forwards Logan Couture of San Jose, Tyler Seguin of Boston, Michael Grabner of the New York Islanders and Tyler Ennis of Buffalo, as well as Montreal defenseman P.K. Subban and Carolina's Jamie McBain.

-- Team Staal. The Staals have the most dynamic forward in San Jose's Couture and the most dynamic rookie defenseman in Montreal's Subban. In a skills competition, that is a huge advantage and gives the Staals a slight edge over Lidstrom in the rookie department.


This is often the tiebreaker whenever you examine the strengths and weaknesses of teams as loaded as these. Each has a number of intangibles working in its favor. Lidstrom is perhaps the most revered player in the League, and every player on his roster will want to win for the classy captain. Lidstrom also has Thomas as one of its goalies, and his battling attitude will rub off on everybody in the dressing room. The Staals answer with a huge hometown flavor, possessing all three Carolina Hurricane players. Plus, the Staal brothers -- Eric and Marc-- are on the same team and will have an incredible bond.

-- Team Staal. There's no bigger advantage than having the crowd on your side -- and, make no mistake, Team Staal will be the fan favorite on Sunday and will have no trouble feeding off that energy. The question then becomes how Team Lidstrom will respond to wearing the black hats -- or helmets, if you will -- in this exhibition.

View More

The NHL uses cookies, web beacons, and other similar technologies. By using NHL websites or other online services, you consent to the practices described in our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service, including our Cookie Policy.