"Innocent lives are being put in danger and that doesn't make sense to me," Joseph wrote. "We need to focus on the solution."
McElhinney wanted to support his teammate. But he didn't know what to say.
"I didn't really feel qualified to put it down in words," he recalled.
The goalie had another idea though.
Lying around his home in Steamboat Springs, Colo. was a blank goalie mask he'd been meaning to get painted.
He called Joseph, asked him if he'd be interested in designing something for the mask. Something to "express a little bit of the situation and the situation that's been going on in our country," McElhinney explained.
Joseph didn't hesitate.
He was in.
"This is a concrete action of doing something that is meaningful and it's definitely showing a lot of support," Joseph said. "I was really honored for him to ask me that."
Joseph checked with McElhinney if he was sure this is the action he wanted to take. Goalie masks are unique in hockey in that they allow the wearer to express their individuality in a sport where homogeny is the norm. "I feel like they're so personal for a goalie to put some design and art on your mask," Joseph said.
"Yeah, absolutely," McElhinney responded.
---
Over the next two weeks, Joseph thought about what he wanted to put on the mask. At first, he wanted a couple quotes and images of people tied to social injustice. But he also remembered the New York Rangers' Alexandar Georgiev had painted a similar mask during the pause, one with a quote and picture from Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.
"I didn't really want to copy that," Joseph said.
He started thinking about athletes that not only had an impact in their sport but were also trailblazers in the fight for equality for all. He shared his ideas with the mask's painter, David Leroux of Diel Airbrush.
"The next day, Dave's like, 'What about this? And what about this?'" Joseph said. "And then we would text here and there. I think it was an easy process, and I enjoyed the collaboration."
Instead of an image of Dr. King, the two found a quote that seemed to fit perfectly.
"Lightning makes no sound until it strikes."
The quote went on the back of the helmet above the Lightning logo
"It's a powerful quote, and also it matches the Lightning a little bit," Joseph explained.
Covering the chin is a fist flanked on both sides by the phrase "Black Lives Matter."