Nothing, it seemed, went right for Tampa Bay against Columbus.
"It's tough to swallow because our expectations, not only outside of the room but inside the room were really high," Lightning head coach Jon Cooper said. "We created those expectations with our play all season long. And they were pretty tough expectations to match. Trust me, everybody in the room, it's killing them more than anybody."
As one-sided as the First Round series ultimately was, it still could have swung the Lightning's way. Game 1 was a killer, the Bolts relinquishing a 3-0 lead under a late Columbus rally and never really regaining their swagger following that staggering loss. The Lightning had opportunities to put that game away too. Would the outcome of the series have changed had Columbus goaltender Sergei Bobrovsky not slid over just in time to rob Nikita Kucherov's power-play one-timer on the doorstep early in the second period, a goal that would have put the Lightning ahead 4-0? Or later on that same power play when Kucherov rifled a shot off the crossbar from the right circle, a shot he made more often than not in the regular season?
"For two periods (in Game 1), there was another team looking for answers [Columbus] and we really weren't," Cooper said. "I think it was a little bit of arrogance in the way we played offensively. It was a bit of a mindset that probably cost us that game and then it went downhill after that. You're not going to win one series in one game, but it really tilted the mindset of the series. And to that, we're culpable, because instead of winning the games 3-0 or 3-1, we wanted to win it 6-1. That mentality cost us a little bit."
The Columbus series is in the past now. The Blue Jackets won their first playoff series in franchise history, and kudos to them for coming into the series with a detailed game plan on how to eliminate the Lightning's speed and skill and frustrate them into what we saw over four games. Columbus is as dangerous an eight seed as the Stanley Cup Playoffs have ever seen, and whichever team has to face them next is in for an immense challenge in defeating them.
Now, it's up to the Lightning, this core group of players and coaches, to learn from the mistakes they made against the Blue Jackets and regroup.
"Now is not the time to make excuses," BriseBois said. "It's the time to show some humility. It's time for us to lick our wounds, roll up our sleeves, get to work and focus on doing what we need to do so that next year we're more successful."
There's precedent for the Lightning to follow too. Two consecutive seasons the Washington Capitals won the Presidents' Trophy and were the League's favorite to win the Stanley Cup only to come up short in back-to-back Second Round defeats at the hands of the Pittsburgh Penguins.
The following season in 2017-18 when nobody really gave them a chance because of the previous two missed opportunities, an under-the-radar Caps team peaked at the right time and won the franchise's first Stanley Cup, defeating the Lightning along the way in a thrilling seven-game series in the Eastern Conference Final.
There are examples outside of hockey as well that show how a major setback can be a defining moment for a group. The University of Virginia was embarrassed by the University of Maryland, Baltimore County in the first round of the NCAA Men's Basketball tournament in 2018, the tourney's top overall team entering the competition becoming the first No. 1 seed ever to lose to a 16 seed in the first round.