Skip to main content
The Official Site of the Carolina Hurricanes

Are the Hurricanes and Panthers Rivals?

by Paul Branecky / Carolina Hurricanes
We mentioned this briefly on Monday’s podcast, but I thought it deserved further discussion here in advance of tomorrow night’s game:

Are the Florida Panthers the Hurricanes’ biggest rival right now? If not, who is?

Paul Branecky
Index | Archive

Most fans might still give Buffalo that dubious honor dating back to the 2006 playoffs, and rightfully so. It was a tough seven-game series that featured a lot of back-and-forth between players and coaches in the media, not to mention fans at the games.

That dislike has lasted well past that year. It seems like Carolina and Buffalo usually play most of their games near the end of the season when a playoff spot is up for grabs, so a lot of those contests, including three yet to come in the coming months, have plenty of intensity.

Also, for what it’s worth, they’re still the only fans who email the webmaster with generic “You Suck!!” comments after they win (Seriously? The webmaster?). Strangely, nothing when they lose …

However, based on more recent events, I think that Florida has to be part of the discussion. It started two seasons ago when the Panthers accused the Hurricanes of diving, leading to several exchanges like this one:

Florida’s Bryan Allen: "He embellished it as much as he could. It's embarrassing the way they play the game. They're looking for the easy way out, taking dives and looking for the cheesy call."

Florida’s Olli Jokinen: "[Carolina] has stolen so many points from us, we have to ... make sure they don't go anywhere. I'd rather see Tampa and Atlanta make it than this team.''

Carolina’s Erik Cole: "If I'm clicking through the NHL package, I'm probably not stopping to watch a Panthers game.”

So, mutual dislike was pretty clear at that point. Then came the final game of last season, in which the Canes only needed to beat the Panthers on home ice – something they had done in every meeting dating back to 2002 - to qualify for the playoffs. Based on past events and quotes like the one above, Florida was motivated beat the Hurricanes despite having nothing else to play for.

Not only did Florida win that game, but they also lost in Washington the following day when a win would have thrown the Canes a postseason lifeline. Not that anyone on the Carolina side expected any favors.

Now, each team finds themselves in a battle to make the postseason in 2009. Both teams are playing well, and it seems like they trade hold of the Eastern Conference’s eighth seed after each game. They play two more times this season, the first being tomorrow night at the RBC Center, which will amount to four-point games in the standings.

So, the question is this: Do the Hurricanes have a rivalry with Florida, or is Buffalo still the more hated team in the eyes of Carolina fans? Could both teams be considered rivals, or perhaps neither?

View More